School Library Journal Starred Review

Gr 5-9-Walker traces the scientific detective work that led to identification of this species, long thought to be extinct, then describes the subsequent investigations of its physiology, habits, and habitat. In words and photos, she introduces the scientists and fishermen involved in the search as well as the rare specimens, which have not survived in captivity and were so difficult to preserve until mid-century. The author mentions the international politics involved in the ownership of the fish as well as misinterpretations of scientific data. As the text moves through the 20th century to recent discoveries in 2001, the photos change from black-and-white shots to color photos enhanced by modern underwater technology. The author ends by cataloging the questions still to be answered. An outstanding history of scientific inquiry, this title will appeal to future oceanographers and excite them with the news that there is still important research to be done.-Ellen Heath, Orchard School, Ridgewood, NJ Copyright 2002 Cahners Business Information.

ALA Booklist (Fri Mar 01 00:00:00 CST 2002)

Walker tells the story of the coelacanth, an ancient fish with a distinctive tail, four stubby bottom fins, and spines on its scales. Known from its fossil remains, this type of fish was thought to be extinct until a scientist discovered one in a South African fisherman's catch in 1938. The hunt was on, and since that time other coelacanths have been found in a few other parts of the world and observed in their habitats deep below the surface of the ocean. Walker writes well, making this relatively unknown area of science history an exciting story of exploration and discovery. Excellent, full-color photos illustrate the text. A behind-the-scenes look at the scientists intently engaged in the study of biology.

Horn Book (Tue Apr 01 00:00:00 CST 2003)

Walker describes the unfolding drama of the decades-long search for more specimens following the exciting 1938 discovery of a coelacanth, previously thought to be extinct. The text reveals how science is affected by forces as powerful as international conflicts and as simple as being in the right place at the right time. Color photos, a map, and source notes enhance the text. Bib., glos., ind.

Kirkus Reviews

Walker ( Seahorse Reef , 2001, etc.) imbues a still-ongoing scientific treasure hunt with all the suspense and excitement it deserves. Drawing information from both published sources and private interviews with research scientists, she chronicles the modern rediscovery of this lumpish, rugged-looking fish, once thought extinct for 70 million years. Her account covers its chance 1938 appearance in a fisherman's net to finds within the last five years that have extended its range to Indonesia and several spots along Africa's eastern coast. Enhanced by lucid art and sharp color photos, and backed up with helpful book and Web site lists, she produces an engrossing tally both of what we know about coelacanth anatomy and behavior, and what remains mysterious. No captured specimens have yet survived more than a few hours, no young have ever been observed, and the purpose of certain organs is still unknown. She makes it easy to understand why, though "it's usually people that catch coelacanths, something about coelacanths also catches' people." Science-writing at its finest, sure to net plenty of young readers. (Nonfiction. 11-13)