ALA Booklist (Fri Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2016)

Ashala, leader of the Illegals, is forced to leave her beloved Firstwood forest when friend and fellow Tribe member Ember Crow goes missing. Following memory-laden clues left by Ember and guided by newcomer Jules, who claims to know where she is, Ashala and her second-in-command, Connor, find themselves caught up in a conspiracy that is much larger and far more complicated than any of the Tribe imagined. The second installment of this dystopian ecothriller holds its own with a surprising revelation that offers an intriguing twist to the trilogy. While the narrative sometimes suffers from constant info dumps (necessary to resolve minor plot holes), and the mechanics of the Tribe's world are far from seamless, aboriginal Australian author Kwaymullina effectively uses speculative technology to illuminate a range of issues teens face today, in particular, bioethics and racism. Readers unfamiliar with The Interrogation of Ashala Wolf (2014) may have difficulty keeping up, but the foundation is laid for an action-packed finale that is sure to reveal even more surprises.

Horn Book (Mon Aug 01 00:00:00 CDT 2016)

Ashala (The Interrogation of Ashala Wolf) and her group of supernaturally gifted young runaways search for missing member Ember Crow. Ash's Tribe works to dissolve divisions in their post-environmental-cataclysm society. Ember reveals herself to be an entirely new kind of being. This action-filled novel--described in an author's note as Indigenous futurism--speaks to technological and ecological concerns with a vigorous futuristic imagination.

Kirkus Reviews

Six months after the events in series opener The Interrogation of Ashala Wolf (2014), the Tribe is thriving; then Ember Crow fails to return from a scouting mission, and Ashala and Connor, searching for answers, make a discovery that upends what they thought they knew about their friend and their own history. When rumors of a man claiming to be the Serpent, a rebel supporting the Illegals, reach the Tribe, they know he's an imposter, a fictional decoy they'd designed themselves to mislead the government. Ember, who's gone to check this story out, instead of returning, sends Ashala a memory message stone via her dog, Nicky, saying she thinks she knows the imposter's identity. Should Ember fail to return, they are not to look for her. Ashala's determined to help anyway, but it won't be easy. Her Sleepwalking (active dreaming) ability is becoming unreliable, and her snake grandfather's warning to "beware the angels" confuses her. Ashala will need more than her ability, he says; she must understand her power. Searching Ember's lab presents new mysteries. When a strange young man arrives with a longer message from Ember, Ashala realizes it's time to act. While this second act's pacing is slower and the plot's political machinations more complex than the first volume's, it's seasoned with enough intriguing speculation—what do we mean by "human"? When and why might we want to revisit that definition?—original worldbuilding, and sympathetic characters to hold reader interest. Fresh and fascinating. (author note) (Indigenous futurism. 12-18)

School Library Journal (Tue Mar 01 00:00:00 CST 2016)

Gr 7 Up-In this second installment of the dystopian series, Ashala Wolf's closest friend Ember Crow has disappeared. The series is set in a postapocalyptic Australia where humanity's abuse of the environment has caused societal and environmental chaos called the Reckoning and where young people who have developed strange abilities evade the government by hiding in a wilderness area called the Firstwood. As the story opens, Ashala must return from the wolf world to protect her Tribe and go in search of her missing friend. Her mission is complicated by a cryptic vision in which Grandfather Serpent tells her to "beware the angels" and Ember's own warnings that she hasn't told Ashala the entire truth about her past. As the protagonist and her friend Connor search for Ember, they discover hidden secrets about legendary inventor Alexander Hoffman, who predicted the Reckoning, and Ember's origins, secrets that endanger their Tribe and other people, which will force them to consider what it means to be human. Readers will need to be familiar with The Interrogation of Ashala Wolf (Candlewick, 2014) to understand the events in this one. However, Kwaymullina's rich world-building, which incorporates the worldviews and ancient stories of Australia's indigenous people, makes this series stand out in the crowded field of YA dystopian fiction. VERDICT Purchase where the first book was popular. Kathleen E. Gruver, Burlington County Library, Westampton, NJ