Starred Review for Kirkus Reviews

Lucky Piper Green has a Fairy Tree in her front yard that sometimes yields up treasures—not always what she wants, but what she needs. In this third title in a charming series set on an island off the coast of Maine, the white second-grader finds a loud bosun's whistle in the hole in the trunk of her favorite red maple tree. She would have much preferred a pony, but when her father takes her out to help on his lobster boat, she discovers the whistle attracts a seal. Perhaps she could train it to be a sea pony? Piper is a totally convincing second-grader, full of enthusiasm and grand, but not always realistic, plans. Her narration is a believable stream of consciousness, veering from one topic to another in a way that will be familiar to her readers. Her island home will be less familiar to many of them, and Potter continues to provide interesting details. Serving as the sternman on her father's boat, Piper stuffs dead fish into bait bags and imagines the treasures in lobster traps: "pinchy crabs or starfish or prickly sea urchins or funny-looking sea cucumbers." She does come to realize that the seal is a wild animal and not an appropriate pet, but her wish comes true in a more appropriate way. Cheerful line drawings add appeal. Completely satisfying. We wish for more. (Fiction. 6-9)

ALA Booklist (Sat Jan 01 00:00:00 CST 2005)

Piper finds a bosun's whistle on the morning after a storm tore her father's skiff from its moorings. When they go out to check his lobster traps, she uses the whistle and some lobster bait to teach a seal a trick. Her father objects to wasting bait, until the seal unexpectedly repays them by leading them to the missing skiff. Appealing ink drawings with gray washes illustrate this clearly written, accessible story. This latest early chapter book in the Piper Green and the Fairy Tree series features a perfect blend of childlike fancy and down-to-earth realism, capped with a happy ending.

Kirkus Reviews (Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)

Lucky Piper Green has a Fairy Tree in her front yard that sometimes yields up treasures—not always what she wants, but what she needs. In this third title in a charming series set on an island off the coast of Maine, the white second-grader finds a loud bosun's whistle in the hole in the trunk of her favorite red maple tree. She would have much preferred a pony, but when her father takes her out to help on his lobster boat, she discovers the whistle attracts a seal. Perhaps she could train it to be a sea pony? Piper is a totally convincing second-grader, full of enthusiasm and grand, but not always realistic, plans. Her narration is a believable stream of consciousness, veering from one topic to another in a way that will be familiar to her readers. Her island home will be less familiar to many of them, and Potter continues to provide interesting details. Serving as the sternman on her father's boat, Piper stuffs dead fish into bait bags and imagines the treasures in lobster traps: "pinchy crabs or starfish or prickly sea urchins or funny-looking sea cucumbers." She does come to realize that the seal is a wild animal and not an appropriate pet, but her wish comes true in a more appropriate way. Cheerful line drawings add appeal. Completely satisfying. We wish for more. (Fiction. 6-9)

School Library Journal

Gr 1-3 When Piper's fairy tree brings her a bosun's whistle (a whistle used to signal crew on a ship), she wonders what to do with it. Can it help her find the family's skiff, which was blown out to see during a wicked bad gullywhumper (a bad storm)? It turns out, it can, when Piper meets a seal that seems to respond to the whistle and it leads her and her dad to where the skiff was stranded. The standard spunky girl getting into scrapes storyline is elevated by the unique northeastern island setting and lobster fishing plotline. Cute, expressive black-and-white illustrations add to the appeal of this sweet story. Fans of like Louise Trapeze or Amber Brown may enjoy this.