ALA Booklist
In 1853, Commodore Perry arrived in Edo Harbor, breaking Japan's 250 years of isolation. Against the backdrop of a country poised uneasily on the brink of change, Preus tells the story of the unlikely friendship between Japanese Yoshi and American Jack. While Yoshi is being pursued by vengeful Kitsune, a samurai he unwisely crossed, he runs into Jack, who has dangerously wandered away from the U.S. delegation. Yoshi knows protecting the "barbarian" will get him in trouble, but he's indebted to the boy after Jack helps him escape Kitsune. With the help of adult Manjiro, whom Preus wrote about in Heart of a Samurai (2010), Yoshi helps Jack return to his ship. In an urgent present-tense narrative, Yoshi tries to balance his own beliefs about the unpopular Manjiro and Jack against his own practical need to protect himself. Drawings and traditional Japanese prints interspersed among the chapters add visual interest, and an informative note sifting fact from fiction closes out the volume. Middle-grade readers eager for adventure with a solid grounding in history will be enchanted.
Horn Book
A dozen years after the events of Heart of a Samurai, American ships arrive in Japan to force trade. Preus retells this gunboat diplomacy's world-changing effects through two boys: servant Yoshi (who longs to be a samurai) and cabin boy Jack. Bolstered by period illustration and rich appended material, the book is solidly historical but never forgets to be an adventure story. Bib., glos.
School Library Journal
Gr 5-8 In 1853, Commodore William Perry led a fleet of imposing black ships into Edo Bay and began negotiations that would end Japan's 200-year policy of isolationism. This companion novel to Preus's Newbery Honor-winning Heart of a Samurai (Abrams, 2010) explores the political upheaval during this time through the eyes of two boys, one Japanese and one American. Inquisitive boys with big dreams, Yoshi is a lowly servant to a samurai and Jack is a cabin boy on one of Perry's black ships. Through dual narration and clear, unhindered prose, the boys' perspectives mirror both sides of the tense relations between the two cultures. In a series of coincidences, Yoshi becomes the assistant to Manjiro Nakahama, the protagonist of the previous volume. Readers will be pleased to reacquaint themselves with Manjiro as he takes Yoshi under his wing and plays an instrumental role in negotiations between Japan and America. Though some may find the plot a bit heavy on politics and diplomacy, the story shines when Jack is separated from his party and Yoshi is obliged to shelter him, and the two boys forge an unlikely friendship that transcends cultural and language barriers. A comprehensive author's note fills in the historical context that shapes the narrative and Japanese woodblock print illustrations from the era add atmosphere to the text. VERDICT Bringing life to historical events not often addressed in children's literature, this rich, multilayered novel will be a treat for fans of Heart of a Samurai . Allison Tran, Mission Viejo Library, CA