Publishers Weekly
(Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)
Originally published in France, this math-minded picture book introduces a hulking polar bear who is impressed by his own size. -I-m very big!- he proclaims. -I-m almost a giant!- The other polar animals nearby dismiss his size: -You-re not that big,- suggest two walruses who swim up to his ice floe. -Look at this: one + one. We two are just as big as you!- The addition theme continues as three foxes, four sea lions, five penguins, and six sardines hop on each other-s backs to show Bear that they are just as large as he is. In minimalist illustrations that resemble screenprints, Philipponneau and Enjary create rich contrasts by using a color scheme of vivid mint green, black, and white. The closing scene-in which Bear remembers that his mouth is pretty big, too-will leave readers giggling. Ages 3-5. (Oct.)
School Library Journal
(Sat Oct 01 00:00:00 CDT 2016)
PreS-Gr 1 A polar bear stands on a chunk of ice and boasts of his size. When the other animals hear, they stand on one another's heads to show him that he's not that tall. The walruses teeter beside him and say, "We TWO are just as big as you!" As the tower of animals grows in size, so do the opportunities for counting and addition. The ending is something of a shock, but being that the main character is a wild polar bear, the last creatures who question his height (six sardines) make a perfect breakfast. The black-and-white illustrations are striking against the green sky. The column of animals on the right-hand page match the column of addition in the text on the left-hand page. VERDICT A picture book for children who like a bit of a surprise when they are learning their numbers. Tanya Boudreau, Cold Lake Public Library, Alta., Canada
ALA Booklist
(Sat Oct 01 00:00:00 CDT 2016)
In this simple, well-designed counting book, a polar bear declares that he is very big ("I'm almost a giant!"), and other mostly cold-climate creatures set out to prove otherwise. Two walruses, one on top of the other, show that they are just as big as the "very big" bear, as do three foxes, four sea lions, and five penguins. The final group is made up of sardines, and the polar bear, in a surprise ending, decides that six sardines are the perfect size r his breakfast. White pages with a few lines of text alternate with pages filled with unadorned three-color illustrations in a silkscreen or linoleum-block style. The white bear is rendered in sharp contrast to the other creatures, done mostly in black with touches of white and teal. All stand out against the spare teal background. An enjoyable read for younger readers content to stop counting at six and who won't question the coexistence of penguins and polar bears or the relative size of the different creatures.