Kirkus Reviews
A small goat with a disability stars in this animal-rescue success story. Already the subject of several online videos, Polly is introduced here with cozy painted illustrations centering on a floppy-eared kid and featuring only partial views of her white human "mom." Virtually blind and taken in by Lauricella, the proprietor of a New Jersey rescue facility called "Goats of Anarchy," Polly finds comfort swaddled in a soothing blanket at first. But that slips off when she wanders around the house, so she is dressed in a toddler-sized Halloween duckling costume—a solution that not only keeps her content but cranks the cuteness factor up about a thousandfold as she draws a diverse audience of fascinated children at the grocery store and later gambols in a grassy field with Pippa, another rescued kid who becomes a constant companion. The author adds anthropomorphic language to this simple profile (" ‘Where's my mom?' wondered Polly") but closes with notes on Polly's "true story," illustrated, rather counterintuitively, with photos of the caprine fashion plate modeling several outfits. Adorable but not exactly substantial. (Informational picture book. 4-6)
ALA Booklist
(Fri Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2017)
This picture book, the first in a projected series, tells the true story of Polly, a blind baby goat that was rescued by the nonprofit group Goats of Anarchy, run by Lauricella, which raises special-needs goats on a sanctuary farm. Children, many of whom may be familiar with GOA's wildly popular Instagram feed, will need no urging to pick up this engaging account of animal rehabilitation. The story reveals how the blind rescue goat learned her way around her new home by following the sound of Lauricella's voice and footsteps. At first, Polly's anxiety could only be calmed by being swaddled in a blanket, but when Lauricella tried putting her in a child's cozy duck costume, Polly blossomed into a confident, happy kid. The illustrations, done with sweeping brushstrokes that give texture to the hills and trees of the farm, lend the book a gentle, friendly feel, and the final pages contain actual photos of Polly. Funny and heartwarming, this story contains great lessons on generosity, caring for animals, and coping with disability.