School Library Journal (Tue Aug 01 00:00:00 CDT 2017)

Gr 9 Up-hen a DNA test shows that Daria, proud Iranian American, isn't Iranian at all, a search for her identity leads all kinds of unexpected places. Daria keeps her discovery a secret while seeking out her birth mother and butting heads with her mother over her Sweet 16. None of her closest friends know how to help. While the voices of underrepresented populations are welcome and well wrought, the same cannot be said for the plotting of this novel. The first half is enjoyable, but the book never recovers from an unearned and uncharacteristic dramatic moment of rebellion from the main character. The rest of Daria's clique, who call themselves the Authentics, are well characterized, and two of the girl members of the group bring a different dynamic to their interactions. The boy, however, with his friend zone plot, is more two-dimensional, and while the conflict with the pretty girl former-friend is culturally specific, it feels clichéd. VERDICT Charming but ultimately flawed. Worth adding to large collections, but not a priority buy.L. Lee Butler, Hart Middle School, Washington, DC

Starred Review for Kirkus Reviews

Fifteen-year-old Daria is determined to fight against her mother's party-planning for the extravagant Sweet 16 she doesn't want, but the battle she is not prepared for comes when she discovers family secrets that turn her world upside down. Daria is proud of her Iranian culture but wants no part of the posh Beverly Hills Persian community. She finds solace with the Authentics, her small, diverse group of friends who have proven to her that they are real, and she nurses resentment toward the Nose Jobs, a group of pretentious Persian princesses led by her former best friend, Heidi. When Daria begins researching her family history for a school project, she makes some unexpected discoveries that challenge her senses of herself and her family. She loses trust in her parents and turns to her friends, but even they fall short of her standards of complete honesty. Having fallen for a Mexican guy her parents would never approve of adds excitement and romance but also brings her crisis to a boiling point. The ferociously authentic Daria is a memorable protagonist, narrating in a trenchant, self-aware past tense that carries readers through her personal cultural minefield. Her gay brother and his husband are but one small detail that celebrates the complexity of and diversity within modern American Islam. Full of surprises both cultural and emotional, and narrated in the strong voice of a memorable protagonist, this is a tale of integrity, identity, family, love, and sacrifice that is sure to satisfy. (Fiction. 11-18)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

What begins as an English class assignment transforms into a messy but fulfilling journey of self-discovery for a Beverly Hills teen in this first YA title from screenwriter and novelist Nazemian (The Walk-in Closet). The project is simple: the students must present the stories of how they got to where they are today, but 15-year-old Daria Esfandyar gets startling results from a genealogy test she takes with her friends, learning that she is half Mexican and not fully Iranian as she thought. Struggling with her sense of self after determining that she was adopted, Daria buries the hurt and betrayal she feels toward her parents and sets out to find her biological mother. She finds the woman-s stepson first and romantic sparks fly. Nazemian raises thought-provoking questions about what -authenticity- means; Daria and her friends, aka the Authentics, pride themselves on keeping it real. Daria-s struggles will resonate with readers who have felt like they don-t know where they belong or who they want to be, and certainly with the children of immigrants who feel caught between worlds. Ages 13-up. Agent: Mitchell Waters, Curtis Brown. (Aug.)

Starred Review ALA Booklist (Thu Jun 01 00:00:00 CDT 2017)

Starred Review Daria despises the pretenses of the so-called Beverly Hills Persian princesses, which include nose jobs, lavish sweet sixteen parties, and ignoring the current state of Iran. That's why Daria and her friends call themselves the "Authentics." Daria is proud to own her Iranian heritage, just as the other Authentics embrace their own unique identities. Things begin to unravel when Daria receives the results from a DNA kit that reveal she is actually half Middle Eastern and half Mexican. Dismayed, Daria secretly begins an investigation to find her birth parents. In the sequence of surprises along the way, Daria continually reevaluates the meaning of identity and authenticity. Author Nazemian weaves a network of diverse supporting characters that further explore these themes, such as Daria's older brother and his Chinese American husband, who are expecting their first child, and Daria's birth mother's attractive stepson. Nazemian keeps it all real by focusing on the strength of emotional bonds that transcend all external differences. Daria's mother, for example, could easily be a Persian princess stereotype, but she is ecstatic about her gay son and the arrival of her first grandchild. As with the novels of Benjamin Alire Sáenz or Randa Abdel-Fattah, Daria's thought-provoking journey will resonate with teen readers of all backgrounds.

Voice of Youth Advocates (Thu Apr 28 00:00:00 CDT 2022)

Daria is deeply proud of her Iranian American heritage, and dubs her closely-knit group of friends “the Authentics,” as they value individuality and shun the myriad of status-seeking, social-climbing impulses embraced by their wealthy Beverly Hills friends and families. This attitude continually puts her at odds with her perfectly posh mother, especially as her lavish sweet sixteen party is being planned (rite of passage is receiving her first Chanel purse). Worse, Daria’s DNA test for a school heritage assignment reveals that she is adopted. Suddenly, everything she once believed is gone, replaced by the frightening question of how to remain true to herself without knowing her biological past? She quickly locates and arranges to meet birth mom, who proves to be welcoming and warm, bringing resolution to Daria’s fears. Likeable Daria narrates; her sharp observations regarding the wealthy’s attempts to outdo one another are wickedly funny and unsettling. The diverse cast of characters includes Daria’s gay brother and his husband as well as Daria’s Mexican crush, and the absolute acceptance with which everyone is treated highlights the many layers of Iranian American culture. The many lengthy descriptions of Daria’s angst and increasingly rebellious behaviors after locating her birth mother, while enjoyable, feel contrived and unfinished, detracting from the more important themes and messages of the novel. Daria’s meeting with her birth mother emphasizes similarities over differences among people, and her heritage and individuality are enriched rather than changed. Nazemian’s novel is surprisingly powerful and will appeal to any reader searching for identity and belonging, particularly those whose lives include two different cultures.—Lisa A. Hazlett.

Kirkus Reviews (Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)

Fifteen-year-old Daria is determined to fight against her mother's party-planning for the extravagant Sweet 16 she doesn't want, but the battle she is not prepared for comes when she discovers family secrets that turn her world upside down. Daria is proud of her Iranian culture but wants no part of the posh Beverly Hills Persian community. She finds solace with the Authentics, her small, diverse group of friends who have proven to her that they are real, and she nurses resentment toward the Nose Jobs, a group of pretentious Persian princesses led by her former best friend, Heidi. When Daria begins researching her family history for a school project, she makes some unexpected discoveries that challenge her senses of herself and her family. She loses trust in her parents and turns to her friends, but even they fall short of her standards of complete honesty. Having fallen for a Mexican guy her parents would never approve of adds excitement and romance but also brings her crisis to a boiling point. The ferociously authentic Daria is a memorable protagonist, narrating in a trenchant, self-aware past tense that carries readers through her personal cultural minefield. Her gay brother and his husband are but one small detail that celebrates the complexity of and diversity within modern American Islam. Full of surprises both cultural and emotional, and narrated in the strong voice of a memorable protagonist, this is a tale of integrity, identity, family, love, and sacrifice that is sure to satisfy. (Fiction. 11-18)