ALA Booklist
(Fri Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2017)
Clock towers in India are being destroyed. Time seems unaffected, but Mechanics Affairs in alternate-reality 1876 London sends young clock mechanics Daphne Richards and Danny Hart to investigate, inadvertently placing them in an increasingly tense situation between Indians and their British occupiers. Danny must leave his new love, the Enfield clock spirit (Colton), and Daphne must conquer her anxieties about being biracial (Indian and British). Beyond all this, a secret group wants to bring down all the world's clock towers and forcibly seeks Danny's support. The second book of the Timekeeper trilogy ably develops the main characters and their relationships while conveying something of Indian politics, culture, and geography. The result is uneven, but Sim creates a few steamy gay petting scenes, provides a nifty parallel between Colton's past and Danny's present, and adeptly plants clues that ratchet up the tension before this entry ends in a cliff-hanger. She provides an author's note to address actual versus imagined history, and her acknowledgements indicate that her heritage connects her to the Indian side of her story.
Horn Book
(Mon Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2019)
In the sequel to Timekeeper, Danny Hart and fellow clock mechanic Daphne Richards are sent to India to investigate a series of destroyed clocktowers. Meanwhile, Danny's love interest Colton, a clock spirit, uncovers secrets about his own past. Though the plot gets a bit convoluted, a diverse group of characters and swoony same-sex romance add appeal to the imaginative steampunk adventure.
Kirkus Reviews
(Tue Feb 28 00:00:00 CST 2023)
In 1876, someone is destroying the clock towers that control India's time. In this second volume in Sim's Timekeeper series, readers rejoin teenage clock mechanics Danny Hart and Daphne Richards as they travel to Agra to investigate a series of clock tower bombings. Daphne and Danny are given this assignment because of their recent successes thwarting similar attacks in England—although, startlingly, unlike the attacks the teens witnessed, the tower bombings in India have not actually stopped time. As the mechanics piece together what happened, Danny, a white human, grapples with his illicit relationship with Colton, the male clock spirit that controls time in the tower where Danny is the mechanic. While Danny is away, this tower is attacked, and Colton journeys to India to protect Danny. On the way, Colton learns the disturbing truth behind his origins. Sim is adept at worldbuilding, and the book's romantic scenes sizzle. However, the plot races among an overwhelming number of unresolved conflicts that leave readers unsure what to expect in the sequel. Additionally, mixed-race Daphne's character does not develop much, despite the fact that her late father had a white English father and an Indian mother and that Daphne's trip to India plunges her into speculation about her heritage and identity. The narrative contains factual inaccuracies about the Indian setting that may interrupt the suspension of disbelief among readers familiar with it. Although the story has plenty of ambition and moments of admirably lyrical prose, in the end, it does not fully realize its promising premise. (Steampunk. 14-18)