ALA Booklist
(Sun Jul 01 00:00:00 CDT 2018)
This cheerful, humorous picture book takes on the green-eyed monster of jealousy, by way of a moose and beaver's friendship. Marvin the moose and Woody the beaver are fast friends. One day, a squirrel falls from a tree, and Marvin rescues him, instantly making him a hero throughout the forest. Woody, at first, enthusiastically joins in Marvin's success. But then Marvin rescues a baby bear whose head is stuck in a tree stump, and his celebrity skyrockets, leaving Woody unsure of their friendship and very jealous. Perhaps the most crucial part of this book for young readers is the section showing Woody acting out for any kind of attention, even negative (like from kicking over a squirrel's pile of acorns). A scheme gone wrong reunites the pals and will have young readers in stitches. The illustrations, combining paint, drawings, and ingenious scribbles, make the action pop. Shuttlewood wisely uses silly antics to couch a relevant lesson in how a friend's change in status can spark hard-to-deal-with feelings but be positively addressed.
Kirkus Reviews
Heroism threatens a friendship.Marvin the moose and Woody the beaver are introduced as "best friends," but their friendship is stretched thin after Marvin uses his antlers to save another animal from drowning and becomes "a local hero." At first, Woody is a fan, as he fashions a red cape that Marvin, now "AWESOME FOR HIRE," will sport in his new superhero business venture as one who is "brave, caring ANDunderstanding." Unfortunately, the more Marvin grows in fame and stature (there's even a statue in his honor), the more Woody is consumed by jealousy. Things quickly swirl out of control for Woody as he makes one bad move after another, causing injury and mayhem in the forest. Fortunately, all ends well as Woody performs a rescue of his own and a new statue is erected (featuring Marvin's head on top of Woody's, this looks somewhat like a totem pole). Shuttlewood adds little to the canon of picture-book tales of friendship, and the extreme measures to which the beaver resorts (theft, bullying, and assault) for attention may raise eyebrows. The cartoon-style illustrations are colorful but very busy, and the pages are often filled to overbrimming with creatures of the forest. There is a lesson about true friendship here, but the action-figure moves muddy the message. (Picture book. 4-7)
School Library Journal
(Thu Aug 01 00:00:00 CDT 2019)
PreS-Gr 1-Being best friends with an awesome forest hero isn't easy, as Woody the beaver learns when his best friend Marvin the moose saves a squirrel from danger. Before Woody knows it, Marvin has gone from a local hero to a forest celebrity. A statue of Marvin has even been erected in the forest. Woody, however, has been left alone because Marvin is so busy, and he is seriously jealous and lonely. In order to garner some attention of his own, Woody starts acting out. He destroys the work of others (kicking over a carefully created pile of nuts) or tosses items onto the forest friends. For his final prank, Woody steals the statue of Marvin, intending to later "find" it to great adulation, but the statue breaks loose from Woody and careens toward a rabbit family. Luckily, Marvin and Woody are able to work together to save all the bunnies from harm, and Woody re-carves the statue to recognize both of the awesome friends. Young children will enjoy Woody's silly, misguided, and loyal actions. The illustrations are amusing as well as a bit slapsticka moose standing on two legs with a red cape and red eye mask would make just about anybody smileand capture the ups and downs of the two friends. VERDICT An enjoyable story showing the pitfalls of being famous as well as the joys of having a true friend.-Sally James, South Hillsborough Elementary School, Hillsborough, CA