ALA Booklist
(Tue May 01 00:00:00 CDT 2018)
Rashin is excited about her first trip to an American beach. As she and her family make their way from Brooklyn to Coney Island, Rashin recounts another beach trip e to the Caspian Sea, in Iran, where she's from. That adventure begins with a special halim (savory porridge) breakfast, a five-hour drive through the forest, and a picnic lunch. She has sweet memories of swimming with her best friend, Azadeh, and eating saffron ice cream, so this trip is laden with hope. Readers might be surprised to learn about Iranian beaches being segregated by gender, with Islamic beach guards enforcing the rules. Vibrant illustrations bursting with color and texture complement Rashin's anticipation, especially when she sees an ice-cream truck by the beach. Disappointment hits hard, however, when there is no saffron flavor t it is short-lived. After all, Coney Island has much to offer, and all ends well. This charming story is a perfect summertime pick and a refreshingly upbeat, relatable account of an immigrant experience.
Horn Book
(Wed Aug 01 00:00:00 CDT 2018)
Kheiriyeh bases her entertaining, heartfelt story on memories of family outings to the beach. Narrator Rashin compares the (sex-segregated) beach in her birthplace of Iran to her new beach in Brooklyn; she especially misses her best friend and saffron ice cream. A sensory text evokes the sights, sounds, smells, and tastes experienced along the journey from each home to the beach. The textured oil and acrylic illustrations are bright and colorful, with context-setting touches.
Kirkus Reviews
Rashin, a young Iranian girl living in Brooklyn, heads to the Coney Island beach with her family, reminiscing on similar outings she had in the past to the Caspian Sea in Iran and comparing those to the present trip.At the center of the story are two short anecdotes: One involves three little boys breaking the rules of the gender-segregated, curtain-split Iranian beach and taking a peek on the other side of the divide where women gather. The ensuing chaos is vividly described and illustrated by Kheiriyeh—with women "shouting and jumping out of the water and covering themselves with towels, newspapers and umbrellas." Order and harmony are, however, soon restored after female members of the Islamic beach guard—depicted as stern, unsmiling women in black attire—patch the holes in the fabric and allow for beach activities to resume. (Since there's been no connection made between Islam and the segregated beach, the episode may require unpacking for children unfamiliar with the practice.) The second anecdote, which inspired the title of the book, tells of Rashin's sadness in not finding saffron-flavored ice cream. Her sadness is quickly overcome after a newfound friend, Aijah, a pigtailed black girl, suggests she try a new flavor, chocolate crunch, which she readily enjoys. Lively and imaginative illustrations on two-page spreads adorn the simple premise of the book—a juxtaposition of two beach experiences, one Iranian and one American.Genuine. (Picture book. 4-8)