Starred Review for Kirkus Reviews

An ancient war draws to a climax as a vengeful—and literally hard-nosed—sea captain seeks out a demonic killer.Ness (Release, 2017, etc.) mines Moby-Dick for incidents and motifs, pitting men against whales in a futuristic alternate world. Along with telling the tale from a young whale's point of view, he reverses the usual orientation of the universe so that cetacean crews go down to meet their enemies at the threshold where oceans give way to the deep, unknowable Abyss of air. In a conflict that has raged for millennia, both sides wield harpoons and store their savagely dismembered opponents in wooden hulls for transport. Having seen her own mother ambushed and torn to pieces, Bathsheba eagerly joins Capt. Alexandra, who bears the stub of a harpoon in her head, in ramming ships to splinters. But the reflective narrator catches profound glimpses of how destructive implacable mutual hatred can be to both body and soul as her captain's obsessive search for the white ship of the universally feared Toby Wick leads through massacres and chancy encounters to a melodramatic confrontation. The story, though far shorter than its progenitor, conjures similar allegorical weight by pairing the narrative's rolling cadences with powerful, shadowy illustrations featuring looming whales, an upside-down ship in full sail, and swarms of red-eyed sharks, all amid dense swirls of water and blood.Wrenching, dark, and powerful—no fluke, considering its model. (Fantasy. 13-15)

School Library Journal Starred Review (Wed Aug 01 00:00:00 CDT 2018)

Gr 7 Up-As a young whale, Bathsheba was all too eager to join Captain Alexandra's crew hunting men for vengeance and the raw materials used in everyday whale life. But after years spent working her way up to Third Apprentice on the fiercest crew in the sea and sailing down toward the air-filled Abyss to hunt men, Bathsheba has begun to question the raw hatred that drives hunters in their constant war. Bathsheba's weary narrative is heavy with foreshadowing and circumspection as she relates the events that set her crew on a fateful hunt for the man Toby Wickthe devil known to whale and man for his terrible deeds and his fierce white ship. Ness channels Melville's original language well and uses the structure of Moby-Dick as a framework for this fast-paced and streamlined retelling filled with philosophical meditations and cautions against the violence of war and the power of prophecyespecially self-fulfilling ones. Cai's accompanying illustrations interspersed throughout bring the depths of the ocean to life with jarring, full-color artwork that calls back to the haunting setting and anguished tone of the narrative. VERDICT An excellent, stirring counterpoint to the original text, rife with questions about the inexorable nature of belief and violence. Emma Carbone, Brooklyn Public Library

Horn Book (Mon Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2019)

Bathsheba lives in a futuristic whale society that has adopted many customs of seafaring humans; they explore, hunt, and use ship-building technology. Led by Captain Alexandra, the pod "hunt[s] for a legend, a myth, a devil": Toby Wick, a human whale-killer. Their fantastical, violent quest is infused with Ness's powerfully made allusions to Moby-Dick and richly illustrated with Cai's swirly, atmospheric art.

Kirkus Reviews (Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)

An ancient war draws to a climax as a vengeful—and literally hard-nosed—sea captain seeks out a demonic killer.Ness (Release, 2017, etc.) mines Moby-Dick for incidents and motifs, pitting men against whales in a futuristic alternate world. Along with telling the tale from a young whale's point of view, he reverses the usual orientation of the universe so that cetacean crews go down to meet their enemies at the threshold where oceans give way to the deep, unknowable Abyss of air. In a conflict that has raged for millennia, both sides wield harpoons and store their savagely dismembered opponents in wooden hulls for transport. Having seen her own mother ambushed and torn to pieces, Bathsheba eagerly joins Capt. Alexandra, who bears the stub of a harpoon in her head, in ramming ships to splinters. But the reflective narrator catches profound glimpses of how destructive implacable mutual hatred can be to both body and soul as her captain's obsessive search for the white ship of the universally feared Toby Wick leads through massacres and chancy encounters to a melodramatic confrontation. The story, though far shorter than its progenitor, conjures similar allegorical weight by pairing the narrative's rolling cadences with powerful, shadowy illustrations featuring looming whales, an upside-down ship in full sail, and swarms of red-eyed sharks, all amid dense swirls of water and blood.Wrenching, dark, and powerful—no fluke, considering its model. (Fantasy. 13-15)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

Like Melville-s Moby Dick, on which it is based, Ness-s profound tale is one of obsession and prophecy, with a twist-it-s told from the whale-s perspective. The narrative introduces readers to a flipped world in which a technologically advanced Cetacean society dominates the oceans. -Call me Bathsheba,- the whale narrator intones, recounting her pod-s ill-fated hunt for the mythical human killer of whales, Toby Wick (-Our devil. Our monster. Our myth-). Led by Captain Alexandra-the most storied of the captains, a harpoon buried in her head-Third Apprentice Bathsheba and the Alexandra-s other apprentices happen upon the wreck of a human ship. They find a single man alive, his hand protruding from the hull and clutching a disk (a message? a map?). Realizing they are on the trail of Toby Wick, the whales take the human hostage, then take to the hunt. In expansive illustrations by Cai (Tintinnula), rendered in inky washes and linework that mimics the ocean-s currents, the whales fly through the water, rendered above, not below, the air-filled -abyss- that humans inhabit. The whale epic, particularly Bathsheba-s discussions with the human hostage, mounts an exploration of inherited prejudices, violence justified, and the far-reaching consequences of war. Ages 13-up. Author-s agent: Michelle Kass, Michelle Kass Assoc. (Sept.)