Kirkus Reviews
A little boy finds wondrous treasures everywhere.A feather, a shiny coin, and other small objects are all wonders to collect and enjoy. One day he sees a lovely star lying in the grass in the park. His big sister, the narrator, thinks it must belong to someone, so they ask everyone they see, but no one claims it. The boy loves that star and takes it everywhere he goes, kept safely in a jar. The star is bright, but it seems sad. When a message in the night sky tells them that the other stars are searching for their lost friend, the siblings try to send the star home. But their voices cannot be heard so far away, and they can't climb high enough. Finally an ingenious idea allows the star to return to the sky. The children are innocent believers who know that anything is possible. The big sister is steadfast and immensely supportive of her little brother, narrating the tale with great pride and compassion. Hay carefully keeps an even tone, never letting the whimsy descend into treacle and always maintaining a sense of wonder. Massini's lively and imaginative illustrations beautifully complement and enhance the text, providing additional insights into the children's activities and emotions. Many of the people they encounter are brown-skinned; the siblings are shown as pale-skinned and dark-haired.Tender and loving. (Picture book. 4-8)
School Library Journal
(Sat Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2018)
PreS-Gr 1 What happens when a star falls from the sky? Could it be lost? Kept like a pet in a jar? The answers to these questions are sought by a young boy who has found a special treasure, one not claimed by anyone he knowsnot the sheriff, the fairies, the wizards, or even the lunch lady. Told by the boy's older sister, the narrative follows his attempts to return a small, very unhappy star back to its home. The siblings try to teach it to fly or bounce it back to the sky, but eventually find a solution to free the little star to return "gently back up to the sky" with a light-filled, loving escort. The treasure is now a new friend, a nightly reflection of a good deed. While varied fonts and font sizes accentuate text, detailed softly painted images highlight expressions with simply drawn faces, shadow, and light. This reassuring tale features an unseen reward for honesty, perseverance, and ingenuity while emphasizing the value of friendship and the close, loving relationship of siblings. VERDICT A suggested first purchase for all libraries, this selection holds strong appeal for young readers. A perfect choice for bedtime and small group sharing. Mary Elam, Learning Media Services, Plano ISD, TX