ALA Booklist
(Tue May 01 00:00:00 CDT 2018)
Clio is (mostly) positive she and her friends sealed the portal to the Nightmare Realm; but, as she begins her new babysitting job in the town's old Victorian mansion, she questions their success. She doesn't want a repeat of her last experience, when she had to call her BFFs to help her out. Her new charge, Minna, is a delightful girl, but Clio suspects the house is haunted. For example, the old clock in the hallway stops ticking when she touches it and chimes whenever she walks by. Furthermore, each time she stays with Minna, something strange happens. Clio's fear grows and she finally engages the help of her friends and Ethan, a new boy in their class. A visit to the library reveals that one of the twin daughters of the mansion's original inhabitants went missing, leading the kids to determine that the spirit of one twin is seeking the other. But which one? And can they help? Shepherd's second entry in the Babysitting Nightmares series is not as creepy as the first, but is just spooky enough, especially around Halloween.
Kirkus Reviews
When strange things happen at Clio's new babysitting gig, her friends are ready to help in this sequel to The Shadow Hand (2018).Clio and her friends have just closed the portal to the Nightmare Realm, but their adventures aren't over yet. Clio starts babysitting for the Lee family, who just moved into the old Plunkett mansion. Creepy things happen the first night, and it gets stranger every time she goes. She discusses the phenomena with her friends, who try to convince her that nothing's wrong until the evidence is undeniable. Luckily, a boy from school named Ethan just happens to show up at Clio's aunt's shop with a flier about his services, which include speaking with ghosts. They are skeptical, but Clio decides to get his help to find out who is haunting the mansion and what they want. In an intense séance, they encounter the ghost and help her find peace. The plot moves slowly through the first half of the book, but the steady buildup of bizarre incidents combines with the characters' interesting enough personalities to keep most readers going. The characters' diverse ethnic backgrounds are casually mentioned: Clio is black with natural hair, and her aunt, Kawanna, has dreadlocks; Maggie and Ethan are both white; Rebecca is Chinese-American; Tanya, who's probably Latinx, has brown skin; and the Lees are Korean-American.Mitigating the slow buildup is the rousing climax, complete with icky creatures and spooky thrills. (Paranormal adventure. 8-12)