ALA Booklist
(Fri Feb 01 00:00:00 CST 2019)
In this sequel to Andros' series opener, Charlotte the Scientist Is Squished (2017), rabbit Charlotte is influenced to undertake another science experiment when her grandpa, as well as the other animals, all come down with a terrible tummyache. Summoning scientific skills she honed with her grandpa, she begins to collect medical histories and specimens, and, though her results are initially inconclusive, she doesn't give up. Even after a group of doctors don't take her seriously, she still perseveres and makes a surprising and useful discovery. Farley's comical cartoon illustrations of Charlotte, a rabbit in a lab coat and goggles, and the other forest creatures make this story of scientific inquiry and experimentation go down easy. Andros nicely emphasizes research methods, confidence, resilience, and the importance of curiosity to scientific vocations. A helpful list of science-related vocabulary terms in the glossary only adds to the STEAM appeal. A nice match for Mary GrandPré's Cleonardo: The Little Inventor (2016) or Andrea Beaty and David Roberts' Ada Twist, Scientist (2016).
Kirkus Reviews
Another win for the scientific method, as the furry young researcher sets out to investigate a wave of malaise sweeping the forest, having already investigated space in Charlotte the Scientist Is Squished (2017).What could be the cause of this sudden rash of upset stomachs and bowel issues? Kitted out in Farley's genial cartoon illustrations with a white coat and a stethoscope just like her beloved grandpa, and inspired by his expressed belief that she is destined "to make a real difference in the world," bunny Charlotte determinedly seeks an answer. Stubbornly pursuing a cure despite the dismissive attitudes of scientists called into consult, she persists. A round of interviewing patients, gathering specimens ("Next!" she calls, seated on a stool outside the outhouse), and dissecting data later, a pattern emerges—a "curious carrot connection." Yes, everyone's been nibbling on carrots…carrots, it turns out, infected with "Funky Forest Fungi." A "customized carrot corrective" from her lab, plus a clinical trial to make sure the cure has taken, soon puts the forest residents back on their paws. Andros lays on the congratulations with a trowel at the end ("Charlotte realized she didn't have to be the oldest or smartest," etc.), but she closes with a glossary of such useful terms as "hypothesis" and "quarantine."More an alliterative self-esteem builder than an exploration of systematic science, but its attractive rabbit protagonist is a sweetie. (Picture book. 6-8)