Perma-Bound Edition ©2019 | -- |
Library Binding (Large Print) ©2022 | -- |
Paperback ©2019 | -- |
Ethnicity in children. Juvenile fiction.
Jews. United States. Juvenile fiction.
Chinese Americans. Juvenile fiction.
Families. Juvenile fiction.
Grandmothers. Juvenile fiction.
Friendship. Juvenile fiction.
Ethnicity. Fiction.
Jews. United States. Fiction.
Chinese Americans. Fiction.
Family life. Fiction.
Grandmothers. Fiction.
Friendship. Fiction.
United States. Social life and customs. 20th century. Juvenile fiction.
United States. History. 1945-. Juvenile fiction.
United States. Social life and customs. 20th century. Fiction.
United States. History. 1945-. Fiction.
Gr 4-8It's 1983, and David's got worries: his impending bar mitzvah, his constantly competing Chinese and Jewish grandmothers, the cute girl who makes him nervous, and his popular new friend, who dislikes David's longtime best friendplus, it's the height of the Cold War, and nuclear annihilation could hit at any second. David's lightly anxious tone; the progressively funny handful of short, dialogue-based scenes per chapter; the realistically kooky family members; and the 1980s middle-class suburban setting are so strongly reminiscent of Judy Blume's "Fudge" books that a well-versed reader might accidentally refer to the protagonist as "Peter." The authors cram in a lot of 1980s references (David Hasselhoff, Betamax). It's refreshing to meet a male protagonist who, like Tara in Paula Freedman's My Basmati Bat Mitzvah, is struggling with how to be authentically Jewish in a bicultural family. VERDICT Giggle-inducing, light, and charmingly realistic fiction that will resonate with a wide variety of readers.Rhona Campbell, Georgetown Day School, Washington, DC
ALA BooklistDavid finds his seventh-grade year worrisome in so many ways. Who can teach him how to talk to girls? When will he finally get his long-expected growth spurt? Can his bar mitzvah satisfy both his grandmothers (one Jewish, one Chinese), whose rivalry is long-standing? Will hanging out with popular Scott raise his social status at school above dork level? Is that worth hurting his best friend since second grade? Is nuclear war imminent? Will digging a bomb shelter save him? Set in 1983 to 1984, the novel weaves plot elements together smoothly while incorporating realistic period details. The first-person narrative engages readers with David's candid reflections as well as his droll telling of events, such as the memorably catastrophic Thanksgiving dinner featuring skillful verbal sparring between the grandmothers and a guest who starts out happy to join the family's East-meets-West feast but flees before dessert is served. An appealing historical novel, even for readers resistant to the genre. In a heartening appended note, the authors reflect that each generation deals with its own "overarching threat."
Kirkus ReviewsIn the months leading up to his bar mitzvah, David Da-Wei Horowitz deals with a host of middle school crises, from bickering grandmas and trouble talking to his crush to fearing the possibility of nuclear fallout. It's autumn 1983 in northern Virginia, and seventh-grader David Horowitz, who is Chinese and Jewish, is busy preparing for Jan. 21, 1984: when he's "being bar mitzvahed in front of about a zillion people." But that's only if he lives that long, considering that after watching The Day After, he's worried about what will happen if there's a nuclear holocaust. David's growing friendship with cool-kid Scott, a white boy, revolves around their school trivia team and their secret project: digging a fallout shelter. Meanwhile, at home, David's grandmothers—Wai Po, who lives with them, and Granny M, who lives next door—seem constantly on the verge of starting World War III themselves, bickering over whose culture should take precedence in David's and his younger sister's lives. David is a lovable intersectional protagonist, and the authors imbue his story with period-appropriate details, such as the novelty of divorced parents and Cold War fear. There's a lot to enjoy, but it's David's relationships with his two grandmothers that steal the show, especially when the rivals eventually unite to teach him he's not "half of each" but "all of both." A nostalgic and heartwarming period coming-of-age comedy. (author's note) (Historical fiction. 8-12)
Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)In this sensitively written story from Rosenberg (
Way back in the early 1980s, David Da-Wei Horowitz was an average young man getting ready for a very important Jewish rite-of-passage, his Bar Mitzvah, with non-traditional elements to placate Wai Po, his Chinese grandmother. Attempting to move into the cool group, David and Hector, his best friend from the beginning, might be able to actually do it when Scott invites them to be part of his trivia contest team. Also on Davids mind is the potential, impending nuclear war with Russia and the only slightly-less-worrying concern that classmate Kelli Ann might (or might not) like him back. Dealing with all the familiar middle school struggleslike balancing new friends with old ones, trying to figure out where you fit in the social hierarchy, how to let a girl know you like hergive this story a timeless feel. From the teens to the adults, these engaging characters feel authentic and relatable. The challenges faced by parents and children trying to blend two cultures into one familyespecially with the addition of two strong grandmasbrings some tension and more humor to the story. Including the television movie, The Day After, as both an historical detail and a significant event for the characters who watch it is a clever addition. The short length will draw readers and they will find real enjoyment in this reading experience.Stacey Hayman.
School Library Journal Starred Review
ALA Booklist
Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books
Kirkus Reviews
Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)
Voice of Youth Advocates (Thu Apr 28 00:00:00 CDT 2022)
Wilson's Children's Catalog
The left side of the table was clearly Granny M's dinner: turkey, cranberry sauce, mashed potatoes, spiced apples, homemade bread, sweet potato soufflé, and green bean casserole. On the right side was Peking Duck with plum sauce and handmade wrappers, eggrolls, a whole steamed fish, and a stir-fry of mixed vegetables. That was Wai Po's.
Maybe this was going to be my last Thanksgiving dinner ever. Or anybody's last Thanksgiving dinner. If it was in fact my last Thanksgiving, I supposed I wouldn't want it any other way. I just hoped that they would get along, just this once, so I could have a happy memory.
Mom sat down at the table last, even though it didn't look like she got to cook anything on her menu. She took off her apron and pushed hair out of her face. "Why don't you say the blessing over the Thanksgiving dinner, David," she said.
Granny M didn't miss a beat. "In Hebrew."
"The turkey isn't even kosher," I said.
"It's still good practice," said my grandmother.
What I really wanted to say was, Please, God, don't let the Soviets or my grandmothers blow us up on Thanksgiving Day. But I didn't know how to say that in Hebrew.
Excerpted from This Is Just a Test by Wendy Wan-Long Shang, Madelyn Rosenberg
All rights reserved by the original copyright owners. Excerpts are provided for display purposes only and may not be reproduced, reprinted or distributed without the written permission of the publisher.
A 12-year-old boy is caught in the middle of cultures, friends, and growing up Chinese Jewish American in this acclaimed, hilariously witty, and heartwarming coming-of-age story.
David Da-Wei Horowitz has a lot on his plate. Preparing for his upcoming bar mitzvah would be enough work even if it didn't involve trying to please his Jewish and Chinese grandmothers, who argue about everything. But David just wants everyone to be happy.That includes his friend Scott, who is determined to win their upcoming trivia tournament but doesn't like their teammate -- and David's best friend -- Hector. Scott and David begin digging a fallout shelter just in case this Cold War stuff with the Soviets turns south... but David's not so convinced he wants to spend forever in an underground bunker with Scott. Maybe it would be better if Hector and Kelli Ann came with them. But that would mean David has to figure out how to stand up for Hector and talk to Kelli Ann. Some days, surviving nuclear war feels like the least of David's problems.