Horn Book (Mon Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2019)

Jones's hair-raising account of a 1958 fire in a Chicago school that killed almost one hundred people will surely encourage young readers to think about fire prevention and safety (and probably check for the fire exits in public buildings they visit). The importance of fire safety laws and the dire consequences of overcrowded classrooms is vividly portrayed. The narrative is illustrated with photos and enlivened by interviews with survivors of the tragedy. Reading list. Ind.

Kirkus Reviews

In 1958, a tragic fire consumed a large portion of a Chicago parochial elementary school, taking the lives of 92 students and three teachers.In engaging prose Jones relates the engrossing story of the fast-moving fire that trapped numerous students in overcrowded classrooms. Many factors contributed to the high death toll. The fire spread throughout the building because wooden stairwells that lacked fire doors acted as chimneys to spread the blaze. The school's two alarms did not sound until the fire had taken hold, partly because only the school principal was permitted to pull them. Many of the classrooms on the second floor had few windows, and those were almost out of reach of the young students. Transom windows over hallway doors quickly shattered in the heat, and the classrooms rapidly filled with thick smoke. The fire trucks were first sent to the wrong address, and then, when they arrived, most lacked ladders tall enough to reach the trapped students. The need to address many of these lapses formed the bedrock for subsequent fire codes. Using interviews with numerous survivors that provide a very personal view of the fire, this effort is especially thought-provoking. Many archival illustrations accompany the text, including photographs of the evidently mostly white student body, although the captions sometimes vary little from the narrative. Useful and detailed backmatter rounds out a fine presentation.A riveting exploration of a tragic fire and the improvements in many schools that followed. (Nonfiction. 10-14)

School Library Journal (Sat Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2018)

Gr 5-8 Jones conveys the circumstances and the aftermath of the December 1958 fire at Our Lady of the Angels school in Chicago, in which 92 students and three teachers were killed and 100 more were injured, with verve and sensitivity. The book does an excellent job of describing how the fire started and spread from room to room without letting the narrative stall over details. Quotes and memories from survivors are woven throughout the book and help to personalize the tragedy and to show the significant impact the tragedy had on their futures. The author gives significant attention to the legacy of the fire and its effect on fire codes and school safety procedures going forward. Photographs and drawings interspersed throughout deepen the impact of the narrative by clarifying details and giving an intimate view of those whose lives were forever changed. Extensive suggestions for further reading, notes on sources, and a list of interview subjects are included. VERDICT This moving narrative of one of the most devastating school fires in U.S. history is recommended for middle school nonfiction collections. Kelly Kingrey-Edwards, Blinn Junior College, Brenham, TX