Starred Review ALA Booklist (Tue Oct 01 00:00:00 CDT 2019)

Starred Review This fresh approach to evolution provides young readers with an innovative introduction to natural selection and adaptation. After brief bits about Charles Darwin and his theory of survival of the fittest, two-page spreads introduce flora and fauna from various branches of his classification system, highlighting how certain characteristics supported various life forms' continued existence. For example, the section on "Flats, Tubes, and the Indestructibles" features brief commentary and colorful illustrations of worms (flatworms, Christmas Tree worms), thread-like animals (nematodes and roundworms), worms with legs (or velvet worms), and water bears ny critters that can survive for 30 years without eating d identifies what properties made a difference (developing front and rear ends was a major breakthrough). Subsequent topics include "Armored Animals," "Lots of Legs," "Big Babies," "Running on Tiptoes," and "Mammals that Gnaw" short, selected physical aspects that allowed species to thrive, even if just for a while (sorry, dinosaurs). Satisfying picture captions emphasize how these evolving traits led to the ascendancy of certain species, and also offer well-chosen factoids to further pique readers' curiosity. A boon for STEM collections, this is also a natural for those kids who have already memorized lists of prehistoric raptors and worked their way through the entire animal book canon.

Starred Review for Kirkus Reviews

Both an introduction to Darwinian concepts and an exploration of the Earth's life.Even before explanations of natural selection and species origin, there is a helpful "Geological Time Chart" that explains eon, era, period, and epoch. Following these, double-page spreads show examples of animals, plants, and protists (which are neither) both extant and extinct on the branches of a tree that begins with one-celled organisms and moves into and beyond the category called "Skillful Mammals." The illustrations and layout are spectacular. Stylized animals and plants are solid blocks of color against gradated blue backgrounds. Each spread is headed in sinuous display type; a vibrantly hued tree branch snakes across the page, creating spaces for flora and fauna and fascinating facts about them. Who knew that tardigrades can live for 30 years without eating? And how sly to note that both rats and humans have conquered the world with their generalized diets. The graceful, accessible text respects its readers. Early on, it asserts that "the first living things were simple cells, which were different from non-living things because they could make copies of themselves." Words not defined within the text are captured in an appropriate glossary. There are several references to climate change, the first noting how green plants cooled the planet about 450 million years ago. The text strikes an excellent balance between upholding scientific research and noting its limits as well as its ongoing, self-correcting, nature.Darwin would approve. (index) (Informational picture book. 8-12)

Kirkus Reviews (Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)

Both an introduction to Darwinian concepts and an exploration of the Earth's life.Even before explanations of natural selection and species origin, there is a helpful "Geological Time Chart" that explains eon, era, period, and epoch. Following these, double-page spreads show examples of animals, plants, and protists (which are neither) both extant and extinct on the branches of a tree that begins with one-celled organisms and moves into and beyond the category called "Skillful Mammals." The illustrations and layout are spectacular. Stylized animals and plants are solid blocks of color against gradated blue backgrounds. Each spread is headed in sinuous display type; a vibrantly hued tree branch snakes across the page, creating spaces for flora and fauna and fascinating facts about them. Who knew that tardigrades can live for 30 years without eating? And how sly to note that both rats and humans have conquered the world with their generalized diets. The graceful, accessible text respects its readers. Early on, it asserts that "the first living things were simple cells, which were different from non-living things because they could make copies of themselves." Words not defined within the text are captured in an appropriate glossary. There are several references to climate change, the first noting how green plants cooled the planet about 450 million years ago. The text strikes an excellent balance between upholding scientific research and noting its limits as well as its ongoing, self-correcting, nature.Darwin would approve. (index) (Informational picture book. 8-12)

School Library Journal (Tue Oct 01 00:00:00 CDT 2019)

Gr 3-6 Entwined in Charles Darwin's theories and the tree of life, evolution is clearly explained. Well organized and beginning with a geology time chart, the book breaks out into ever-increasing complexity. Bright covers ancient times and how chemicals and heat acted as an evolutionary catalyst. There is quite a bit in between that is addressed in small bites. Author and illustrator have created a congenial mix, using tree limbs to symbolize the tree of life growing around each distinct blurb and then meandering across the double-page spread. Carpentier has created a bright, cheerful platform for the text. Her depiction of the life form and the tree of life enhances the text's organization, making the huge time spans manageable in this successful overview. In the midst of this undertaking, only one bit of documentation is sharednamely, John Gould's ornithological discoveries and how they influenced Darwin's opus, The Origin of Species . More documentation is needed to cover all the discoveries that Darwin did not make. For example, Darwin did not identify the coelacanth in 1938; according to the Smithsonian Museum, it was discovered by Marjorie Courtenay-Latimer. Back matter consists of a glossary and an index. VERDICT A pleasing visual representation that could benefit greatly from additional documentation. Purchase only if an overview of evolution is needed. Nancy Call, formerly at Santa Cruz Public Libraries, Aptos, CA