ALA Booklist
(Sat Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2018)
One year after a mass shooting, Jessica and Lucas, along with their families, deal with the aftermath of the event that changed their worlds forever. Shy and withdrawn Jessica struggles to recover from the loss of her brother, while also caring for her grieving mother. Angry and anxious, Lucas turns to boxing in order to release his frustrations at being a survivor and losing his brother. Jessica's and Lucas' paths cross, and together they form a bond that is characterized by love, healing, and moving forward. Giles' novel is one of surviving terrible losses and of healing. As in her previous novel, Now Is Everything? (2017), Giles writes from the perspective of young adults trying survive the unexpected. Told in alternating perspectives from Jessica and Lucas, the mass shooting is not the main focus; rather, the lives of those affected by the mass shooting and its aftermath take center stage. Readers will find the latest from Giles a pleasing read.
Horn Book
Jess Nolan and Lucas Rossi demonstrate very different responses to tragedy in the year after a mass shooting at a movie theater in their Queens neighborhood. Eighteen people were killed, including each teen's brother. As Jess's and Lucas's stories converge, their shared loss brings them together in support and love. Giles offers a nuanced portrait of private grief following a public tragedy.
Kirkus Reviews
Two teens who survived a mass shooting find love as they try to pick up the pieces of their lives in the wake of loss and tragedy. It has been a year since a shooting at a movie theater left 18 people dead. Lucas survived but lost his brother, a star football player. Jess survived, but her brother didn't, and her mother has been debilitated by grief. Lucas tries to make sense of his survival by keeping a daily record of his random acts of kindness. Therapy helps, and boxing releases a lot of the negative energy, but he still suffers from panic attacks and avoids talking about his feelings with his parents. Jess finds a job to help with the overdue bills that keep piling up since her mom stopped working, but she can't convince her mother to spend a full day out of bed, and she occasionally depends on weed to get her through her toughest moments. When Jess and Lucas meet at work they are wary of each other, but over time they become close, helping each other through feelings of shame, guilt, and ambivalence about living normal lives after their losses. This sensitive portrayal of the complications of journeying through grief is convincing and moving. Little physical description of the main characters, combined with the awkwardness with which the diversity of very minor characters is made known, accentuates the white default.Thoughtful and thought-provoking. (Fiction. 14-18)