ALA Booklist

When an eight-year-old boy gets a baby sister, his true feelings emerge in a series of letters and drawings addressed to her. At first, there's a lot of antagonism: the narrator draws over-the-top pictures of his sister ("Even though it is not my fault that you look like this, they decided not to put my picture of you in your baby book"), writes her a regular progress report ("whininess: world class"), and sends her birthday cards ("Happy sixth birthday to someone who is still obnoxious"). But 10 years go by, and his attitude gradually softens. The epistolary format is comically complemented by Bluhm's cartoon drawings, appearing in heavy pencil scrawls in the beginning chapters, and in a more refined hand as the narrator's drawing skills steadily improve. Glimmers of plot appear, mostly about the boy's best friend moving away, but more endearing is the slow-but-steady growth of affection. The ending might be a touch schmaltzy for the target audience, but the dry humor and clever format should nevertheless appeal to any kid with a sibling.

Horn Book

A collection of handwritten notes and drawings from a brother to his younger sister documents their relationship. What starts with uncertainty at her birth ("I am not sure I love you yet") grows to an unshakeable bond and reassurance of his love when he leaves for college ("Everything changes. Almost everything"). Humorous and heartwarming illustrations help tell the moving story of siblings confronting challenges together and coming out stronger.

Kirkus Reviews

Over the years, a boy's letters to his younger sister reveal his changing impressions of her and their relationship in this epistolary graphic novel.For the unnamed 8-year-old boy, life was less complicated before his baby sister was born. Now his parents (aka "the wardens") ask him to write cards and letters, sometimes with accompanying drawings, to his new sibling. Beginning each note with "Dear Sister," the boy recounts his life with honesty, expressing his frustration with her incessant crying, having to read her the same book for "the 763rd time," and his lack of privacy. Mixed in are several apology letters that reveal that the wardens fail to understand his perspective. Only his friend Joe offers diversion. Signing his initial letters "From, Brother," he informs his sister that he's holding out on the love part until he's made up his mind. During a 10-year-period, however, his letters gradually reflect his growing affection for her. When Joe moves away, it's the sister, who's always adored her big brother, who understands his pain. And as their friendship and affection grow, perhaps the brother enjoys connecting with—and yes, reading to—his sister after all. While books on sibling rivalry abound, this volume brings freshness to the topic with McGhee's gentle humor and poignant scenarios (though adults may respond more strongly than kids). Bluhm heightens both with childlike sketches for the brother's drawings and emotive illustrations for the storyline.Dear indeed for preteens facing big changes and adults with fond memories. (Graphic fiction. 10-13)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

Letters, drawings, and homemade coupons form this epistolary accounting of two siblings- young life together, a portrait of frustration and love that spans 10 years: from the birth of Sister to her 10th year, when her brother departs for college. The missives Brother sends reveal his feelings-notes their parents (-the wardens-) make him pen, apologies (also forced), and sibling progress reports (-Whininess: Excellent-). Initially, Sister is an annoyance (she cries, insists Brother read a book for the -763rd time,- fails to respect restroom privacy). But affection grows between them, and amusement and tenderness come through in the letters- postscripts (from a note to camp: -PS: I miss you, too-). Drawings by Bluhm complement the handwritten text, mimicking the boy-s sketches and the way they change over time. The authentic sibling relationship may border on nostalgia, but it offers a meaningful look at one of life-s realities: sibling-hood and all its foibles. Final art not seen by PW. Ages 10-up. Author-s agent: Sara Crowe, Pippin Properties. Illustrator-s agent: Larissa Helena, Pippin Properties. (Oct.)