Starred Review ALA Booklist
(Thu Oct 01 00:00:00 CDT 2020)
Starred Review The two latest entries in the Ordinary People Change the World series (2 new titles) continue to deliver accessible history lessons through the charm of youthful comics. In I Am Anne Frank, readers are introduced to Frank as a relatable, everyday girl before she and her family flee from the Nazis, finding their way into the secret annex. Meltzer extolls Jewish values while gently addressing the escalating persecution of Jews and the horrors of the holocaust, acknowledging the terror but framing Frank's story as one of resilience and hope. The girl's narration ends with her still in hiding, and a final, modern-day spread lists pertinent facts, including Frank's eventual death. Older readers will appreciate seeing segments of the diary's text in slivered panels between ever-widening black gutters. This undeniably somber volume is appropriately lightened by Eliopoulos' disarming cartoons, which utilize large panels, speech bubbles, and simple yet expressive character designs. An excellent series th a particular standout in Anne Frank rfect for beginning readers not quite ready for Nathan Hale's Hazardous Tales.
Horn Book
With eight of us crammed together, our world was very small. But if you look for what's good, you'll find it.
Kirkus Reviews
A bobblehead avatar of the teenage writer and symbol of the Holocaust presents her life as an inspiration.From a big-eared babyhood and a childhood spent "writing stories" to fleeing Germany for Amsterdam, Anne's pre-Annex life is sketched. Narrating in the first person, the cartoon Anne explains that Nazis "didn't like those of us who were Jewish or other groups who were different from them." Hitler is presented as a leader "who blamed the Jews for all of Germany's problems, even though we hadn't done anything wrong." Then in short order Anne receives her diary as a birthday present, the family goes into hiding, and Anne finds solace in the attic looking at the chestnut tree and writing. Effectively, Annex scenes are squeezed between broad black borders. Illustrations present four snippets of quotes from her diary, including "I still believe, in spite of everything, that people are truly good at heart." Narrator Anne says, "You can always find light in the darkest places. That's what hope is," as she clutches the diary with Shabbat candles on one side and a menorah burning brightly on the other. In the next double-page spread, an international array of modern-day visitors standing outside the Anne Frank House briefly, in speech bubbles, wraps up the story of the Holocaust, the diary, the Annex, and the chestnut tree. Anne's wretched death in a concentration camp is mentioned only in a concluding timeline. I Am Benjamin Franklin publishes simultaneously. (This book was reviewed digitally with 7.5-by-15-inch double-page spreads viewed at actual size.)A sanitized version of a too-short life. (photos, sources, further reading) (Picture book/biography. 4-8)