ALA Booklist (Sat Aug 01 00:00:00 CDT 2020)

Those who survived strained against the heat after Solís scorched the earth, punishing them for the devastation they brought upon the land. That's why las cuentistas (storytellers) like Xochital were born, to ingest the truth of others and give it back to the desert. But Xo's purpose of serving others breeds a lonely life, one in which she is lied to and used. To find truth and meaning, she embarks on a journey with Emilia, the callous daughter of a murderous man, and uncovers kinship in an unlikely character. Hot off the heels of the well-received Anger is a Gift (2018), Oshiro leaves mouths parched with their second novel, wherein water is prized and mystical magic and creatures loom ever closer. Xochital's deep curiosity for answers and knowledge launches the literal journey most of the pages follow, and though that can slow the pace, the writing, akin to an atmospheric, novel-length poem, seamlessly weaving in Spanish and matter-of-fact queer representation, is beautiful to read. Contemplative teens will appreciate this meaningful story about human existence.

Kirkus Reviews

What does it mean to come into your own power by letting go of it?The villagers of Empalme devoutly pray to Solís, the feared higher power who unleashed La Quema, or fire, on humanity for its ills of greed, war, and jealousy. As the village cuentista, Xochitl listens to and receives the villagers' stories into her body, clearing their consciences, preventing the manifestation of their nightmares, and releasing them to Solís in the desert. Having diligently played this role since childhood, she is now a deeply lonesome 16-year-old whose only comfort comes from cherished poems. Worn weary by her role, she leaves on an odyssey in search of another way to exist. In their sophomore novel, Oshiro deftly weaves an intricate, allegorical, and often gory tale within a post-apocalyptic desert setting that readers will feel so viscerally they may very well need to reach for a glass of water. It is a world parallel to ours, rife with Biblical references and the horrific traps that Latinx immigrants face while seeking better lives. Xochitl's first-person, questioning narration-interlaced with terrifying cuentos that she receives on her journey-is the strongest voice, although secondary and tertiary characters, both human and mythical, are given a tenderness and humanity. All main characters are Latinx, and queer relationships are integrated with refreshing normality.A meditation and adventure quest offering solace to anyone bearing an unfair burden. (Fantasy/horror. 14-18)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

Honesty, the weight of caregiving, and the space between absolution and compassion span deserts in this tender, postapocalyptic Latinx fantasy. As cuentista, restless Xochitl, 16, takes the village of Empalme-s confessions and spills them to the desert and Solís, the departed sun god who scorched the earth in punishment generations ago. When a roaming warlord plots massacre in Empalme, she breaks a cuentista-s strictest law-to magically forget confessions-and runs. But the warlord-s daughter enlists Xochitl-s help to return her home, where another cuentista can dispatch Xochitl-s powers-a journey through shining and ruined desert cities, shape-shifting beasts, hidden poetry, and an ever-unfolding, uncomfortable truth. In a storyteller-s cadences, #OwnVoices author Oshiro (Anger Is a Gift) maps a sincere journey through nuanced struggles: the weight of pain, how hope and complicity feed immigrant exploitation, and breaking flawed social cycles. While not always deft in handling complex moral territory, this ambitious, organically Spanish-studded examination of trauma stays adventurous and accessible, resulting in a grace-filled, loving declaration of human value and worth. Ages 13-up. Agent: DongWon Song, Howard Morhaim Literary. (Sept.)

School Library Journal (Sat Aug 01 00:00:00 CDT 2020)

Gr 9 Up-In a future where the world is mostly dry desert after La Quema burned everything, Xochitl is counted on in Empalme to pass on the truths confessed to her by the villagers to the god Solísan essential task that must be done to keep dark truths from manifesting as dangerous pesadillas. Exhausted from the heavy burden of this ritual and beginning to question her role as cuentista, a role she never chose and does not want to spend the rest of her life doing, Xochitl makes the drastic decision to keep a story her friend gave to hera story that could have dire consequences for Empalme. This act sets off a chain of events that cause Xochitl to abandon her duties as a cuentista and leave Empalme, and which entwines her destiny with that of Emilia, daughter of Julioa dangerous man who brings death with him everywhere he goes. As Xochitl and Emilia embark on their journeys, their separate searches bring their destinies closer together. Exploring the world outside Empalme, Xochitl begins to question everything she thought she knew about herself, the world, and about Solís. VERDICT A cross between Lois Lowry's The Giver and Tehlor Kay Mejia's We Set the Dark on Fire , this haunting story will stay with readers just like the stories Xochitl has kept. Selenia Paz, Harris County P.L., Houston