Something is amiss in Berry Woods!Evie the Strawberry Fairy's magic wand has gone missing, and then Evie notices her strawberries have turned bright blue. This latter occurrence is the titular "strawberry surprise," and Evie is curious but not alarmed. The same can't be said of three friends-an unnamed hedgehog, Summer the Sunshine Fairy, and Laurel the Tree Sprite-who all come to Evie voicing fears about "a scary Hogwitchit [who] has moved into Berry Woods." Summer is fearful after seeing a strange shadow, Laurel's hair is stained orange, and the hedgehog has red splotches all over his quills. Resourceful Evie packs a bag with supplies that end up coming in handy when she and her friends go off in search of the Hogwitchit. Lo and behold, it's actually a vole who prides himself on his berry jam. They quickly discover that the vole mistook Evie's magic wand for a spoon and has been using it to try to make jam, and this mix-up explains all the strange surprises and changes the friends have experienced. Evie quickly puts things to rights and gifts the vole a trowel he can use as a spoon. Everyone enjoys jam cookies at book's end. Dahle's illustrations are as cozy as her story, the interiors of these woodland homes snug melds of nature and found human objects. The animals are lightly anthropomorphized; humanoid characters present White.This German import (by way of Scotland) is sweet as tea cakes. (Picture book. 3-6)