Starred Review for Kirkus Reviews
(Thu Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2021)
Sola's ocean world grows larger even as she encounters an existential threat to her islands' way of life.In this sequel to Island Book (2019), the young sea captain returns to her friend Chief Hunder's Fortress Island with a cargo of lenses. There, Capt. Alef has just arrived with his own find-a set of long-lost objects that form a nautical map to a continent, an infinite land. Alef persuades Hunder to join the voyage of discovery aboard his ship, the Wake. Sola, at odds with Capt. Alef's obsession, sets out to follow and must be rescued from a storm by a ghost ship. The "ghosts"-sailors who make decisions democratically-remember a past of aggressive conquering and believe that the continent must be kept safe. They vote to stop Alef, but Sola's fate is left in doubt by the cliffhanger ending. Sola's green-skinned people stand out among a multihued cast of humanoids with rounded, marine-life features. She encounters some old companions during the voyage and shares a poignant moment of deep connection and a chaste kiss in a brief reunion with her friend Esha. Bright, well-defined panels feature action set against backdrops of sea and sky that are stunning in their visual impact. The concise dialogue telegraphs deeper meanings while leaving much about the characters' relationships and motivations to imagination and individual interpretation.A dazzling mix of excitement and philosophical adventure. (Graphic fantasy. 9-12)
Kirkus Reviews
(Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)
Sola's ocean world grows larger even as she encounters an existential threat to her islands' way of life.In this sequel to Island Book (2019), the young sea captain returns to her friend Chief Hunder's Fortress Island with a cargo of lenses. There, Capt. Alef has just arrived with his own find-a set of long-lost objects that form a nautical map to a continent, an infinite land. Alef persuades Hunder to join the voyage of discovery aboard his ship, the Wake. Sola, at odds with Capt. Alef's obsession, sets out to follow and must be rescued from a storm by a ghost ship. The "ghosts"-sailors who make decisions democratically-remember a past of aggressive conquering and believe that the continent must be kept safe. They vote to stop Alef, but Sola's fate is left in doubt by the cliffhanger ending. Sola's green-skinned people stand out among a multihued cast of humanoids with rounded, marine-life features. She encounters some old companions during the voyage and shares a poignant moment of deep connection and a chaste kiss in a brief reunion with her friend Esha. Bright, well-defined panels feature action set against backdrops of sea and sky that are stunning in their visual impact. The concise dialogue telegraphs deeper meanings while leaving much about the characters' relationships and motivations to imagination and individual interpretation.A dazzling mix of excitement and philosophical adventure. (Graphic fantasy. 9-12)