Kirkus Reviews
An extraterrestrial's search for home turns into a tour of the planets.In the patterned tradition of P.D. Eastman's Are You My Mother? (sort of), green-skinned Beep zooms from planet to planet, but none turns out to be his own "small and red and beautiful" one. With time for just a name and a fact ("Neptune is the windiest planet"), each merits only a quick flyby, being too big or too hot or, anthropocentrically for Earth, "much too busy." When at last small, red, beautiful Mars comes into view, Beep lands his saucer joyfully to find mate and child (or equivalents) waiting. Miller strews his cartoon spaceways with rockets, satellites, sparkly stars, and nonhuman passersby of diverse description. Only at Pluto, which Beep zooms by between Earth and Venus (it's unclear how Houran has plotted Beep's route) and which sports a "Not a Planet Anymore" sign, do the smiles that he puts on the faces of nearly every astronomical body briefly change to frowns: "Oh dear. Sorry about that. Good luck." There is no explanation for Pluto's demotion, not to mention any reference to the solar system's eight other dwarf planets. Pluto does assume its proper station on the closing planetary panorama, but the hand-wavy approach to strict accuracy kicks Earth's moon out to share an orbit with Mars. Fortunately there are enough similar but more detailed tours available that primary level readers inspired by Beep's mini-odyssey to book a deeper interplanetary dive will be spoiled for choice. (This book was reviewed digitally with 8-by-14-inch double-page spreads viewed at actual size.)A tantalizing, if not dependably factual, first flight. (Informational picture book. 5-7)
School Library Journal
(Tue Jun 01 00:00:00 CDT 2021)
PreS-Gr 1 Beep the alien and his robot dog are lost in the solar system and trying to find their way home to their small red planet. As Beep navigates his spaceship near each planet and asks, "Are you my planet?" he points out one way each differs from his own. For instance, to Uranus he says, "You are DEFINITELY not my planet. You're sideways! How nifty!" One short sentence is included on each page to provide more information about Beep's observations, such as that Saturn's rings are made of ice, dust, and rock. Young and emerging readers can predict the pattern created by the repetitive text and can trace the dotted line that maps out the spaceship's trajectory as it travels around each page. Illustrations are vibrant and engaging. Planets are not presented in order and the one-page spread illustrating the solar system is not to scale and difficult to discern the correct orbital order around the sun. Earth's moon appears on the same orbit line as Mars and both Saturn and Jupiter are on three different orbit pathways. VERDICT An optional purchase for libraries in need of introductory nonfiction materials for young readers. Meaghan Darling, Sparta P.L., NJ