ALA Booklist
Lucas spends his summers in Puerto Rico with his dad, who is a reviled American developer building resorts all over the island. Lucas dislikes his father, too, preferring to lose himself in the stories told by the local señoras, especially the one about the cursed house occupied by a poisonous, wish-granting witch. When girls start going missing ter washing up on the beach, covered in blistery rashes cas never dreams that the cursed house could be related. But when he hops over the garden wall of the house on a whim and meets Isabel, the cloistered, ill girl who lives there, he learns there's more truth to the old stories than he could have imagined. While a few relationships and plot points seem a bit flimsy, debut author Mabry cultivates a rich setting, offering lush descriptions of the island, its stories, and the sharp divide between the old world and the incoming new one, characterized by swift modernization and the careless destruction of history. Perfect for fans of Carlos Ruiz Zafón's atmospheric Marina (2014).
Horn Book
Teenage playboy Lucas spends the summers in his real-estate developer father's luxe hotel in Puerto Rico. When girls start disappearing from the island and Lucas's latest hookup ends up dead, he becomes entangled with a creepy botanist and his daughter and is a suspect in the island's foul play. The story, with elements of magical realism, is satisfyingly moody, lyrical, and mysterious.
School Library Journal
Gr 7 Up-This first-person murder mystery is set in Puerto Rico, where Lucas, a biracial 17-year-old with blond hair and blue eyes, finds himself the prime suspect in the murders of two young women. It doesn't help that his hotel-developing American father is wealthy or that he enjoys frequenting parties. Even some of his local friends doubt his credibility given that he discovered the body of one of the victims, the beautiful Marisoland his latest fling. Despite his shock, Lucas continues to be magnetically drawn to the ominous home of the American scientist Dr. Ford with its supposed wish-granting ghost. When he finds the man's spirited daughter Isabel instead, Lucas begins to understand the cause of recent bizarre events, and the two work together in a race against time to prevent further killings. Yet proximity to the girl results in physical illness, as well as a fatalistic attraction despite plagues of mosquitoes and even a hurricane. The magical realism in this book draws heavily on themes related to science and scientific research evidenced in Nathaniel Hawthorne's short story "Rappaccini's Daughter," intertwined with references to legends of Dominican ciguapas beautiful mythic female beings that lure men to their death. The "exotic" foreign setting includes suspicious, gossiping locals; lush landscapes; and extreme weather, together with eerie romance and unexpected perils requiring superherolike resolve and physical stamina. This book will appeal to teens, particularly fans of romance and murder mysteries; however, Lucas's outsider perspective toward the island, particularly at the beginning of the text, tends to mask critical themes of race, power, and identity, as well as the impact of U.S. control in Puerto Rico. VERDICT A complex text best used in book clubs or classrooms where teens can discuss the dominant monocultural readings of the book, as well as the tourist perspectives of Puerto Rico.— Ruth Quiroa, National Louis University, IL