ALA Booklist (Thu Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2021)

Mary Jane Dillard's 14 years have thus far been spent trailing her mother around the kitchen, singing in the church choir, and sitting quietly through meals at the all-white country club. Everything changes for Mary Jane when she takes a summer job nannying for the Cone family, a psychiatrist, his wife, and their five-year-old daughter, Izzy. The Cones are not your typical suburban doctor's family: they're blunt, messy, loud, affectionate, and are temporarily housing a heroin-addicted rock star and his Hollywood actress wife in their attic suite. The Cones and their house guests give Mary Jane a crash course in living out loud, introducing her to new experiences, music, and ideas: bralessness, group therapy, Black-owned record stores, and healthy open marriage. Mary Jane starts to see her President Ford-worshipping parents in a different light, and must reckon with how her past will inform her ever-changing vision for the future. Set in suburban Baltimore in the 1970s, Blau's latest is a charming and poignant tale of desire, image, Americana, and chosen family.

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

Blau (The Summer of Naked Swim Parties) returns with a sweet if simplistic coming-of-age story about a teenage girl-s influential encounter with a rock star couple in 1975 Baltimore. Mary Jane Dillard, 14, the responsible daughter of country-clubbing, conservative Betsy and Gerald, takes a job as a nanny for her parents- free-spirited acquaintances, the Cones: Richard, a psychiatrist; and Bonnie, his bohemian wife. The Cones need Mary Jane-s help with their five-year-old daughter while hosting celebrity couple Jimmy and Sheba as part of Jimmy-s group therapy treatment for his alcohol and drug addiction. Jimmy sings in a popular band, and Sheba stars in a variety show. Soon Mary Jane uses her choir voice to sing in harmony with Jimmy and Sheba, and as she witnesses both couples- emotional outbursts and unadulterated shows of affection, she gains a deeper understanding of the potential of human relationships and of her own musical talent. Mary Jane-s narration can be cloying (-I wondered if the addict would look like the addicts I-d seen downtown from the window of the car,- Mary Jane thinks, anticipating Jimmy-s arrival), and the narrative arc, though shaped by Mary Jane-s eye-opening exposure to the realities of adulthood, is not particularly sophisticated. Still, this might please readers looking to indulge their -70s nostalgia. (May)

Kirkus Reviews

An adolescent girl comes of age in this nostalgic novel of 1970s Baltimore.In the summer of 1975, nothing has stopped earnest 14-year-old Mary Jane Dillard from loyally accepting her strict Presbyterian mother's beliefs about what it means to be a well-behaved young woman. Her familiar world turns upside down, however, when she begins nannying for the Cones, an unconventional family made up of Dr. Cone, a psychiatrist, Mrs. Cone, a housewife who-scandalously-doesn't cook or clean, and Izzy, their winsome daughter. Mary Jane quickly becomes an integral component of the Cone household, not only taking care of Izzy, but also cooking and cleaning for the family. When Dr. Cone welcomes two top-secret guests-a rock star recovering from drug addiction and his movie-star wife-to the household, Mary Jane finds herself getting an unexpected but thrilling crash course in music, fame, sex, and the adult world…one that she's inevitably forced to hide from her conservative parents. Blau paints an overly rosy picture of Mary Jane's coming-of-age: Though the book nominally engages with weighty topics including addiction, adultery, and racism, it fails to seriously reckon with them or with the complex and often ugly history of America in the 1970s. The novel's countercultural setting is, regrettably, mere window dressing. Though Mary Jane's desire to escape her parents' oppressive home is understandable, Blau never critically interrogates the Cones' extreme openness, particularly about sex, which is also inappropriate given the fact that Mary Jane is only 14. With the exception of some clunky dialogue, Blau's novel is readable and modestly entertaining, and readers nostalgic for the rock-and-roll scene of the '70s will likely enjoy its depiction of a wayward star, but it never dares to ask difficult questions.A frustratingly sentimental depiction of adolescence and American counterculture.