Publisher's Hardcover ©2021 | -- |
Refugee children. Juvenile fiction.
Dogs. Juvenile fiction.
Refugees. Juvenile fiction.
Dogs. Fiction.
Refugee children. Fiction.
Refugees. Fiction.
When a family in Colombia has to leave their home behind, their pet dog, Antonia, is also lost.It is estimated there are close to 6 million people in Colombia who have fled their homes because of conflict, violence, or disasters. Having not crossed international borders, they have no legal status as refugees and more often than not become invisible. This wordless picture book attempts to shine a light on one such group of people. Whimsical illustrations show a dog heading to the water's edge, presently joined by a child, then another leading a bird, and then two more with a bird in a cage. Soon there are also adults carrying packages. They board a boat that carries them across the water, and when they disembark, they now traverse a jungle. It is here that the dog becomes lost and also here where the only word in the book appears: "Antonia," as the children call the name of the dog. Seeing the distress caused by the loss, the children with the caged bird release it, though it is hard to see how that helps. The book ends on a less-than-uplifting note as the migrants reach the gray, smoky city-a stark contrast to the lush vegetation of the journey. Without the brief explanation given by the author at the beginning, it would be impossible for readers to discern just from the illustrations why these people are on the move.A baffling story with an obscure message. (Picture book. 5-8)
Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)A note to readers opens Colombian author-illustrator Dipacho-s U.S. debut, explaining that corporations in Colombia are buying up land and displacing -many farmers, and... Black and Indigenous people.- In this mostly wordless story, highlighted by watercolor washes and layered paint, several families, two brown-skinned, one light yellow, leave their homes in search of new places to live; their journey unspools from left to right. The small cartoonlike figures, with bright eyes and distinctive features, carry their belongings in plastic shopping bags and tied-up bundles. One child, who has brown skin and a textured tower of black hair, brings their beloved orange dog, Antonia, who crosses the river in a ferryboat with the families. But during a passage through thick jungle growth, the child and their mother emerge without the canine in tow. They call: -¡Antonia!- In anguish, the child calls again, the name stretching across a spread. The other children console the owner, and one makes a gesture as compassionate as it is unexpected. But the families must go on in this bittersweet picture book, which conveys with power one child-s loss from forced migration. Ages 4-8.
PreS-Gr 2 In a nearly wordless book, a family migrates to a new place and on the way, a child loses her beloved pet dog. In fact, the dog's name, Antonia, is the only text that appears in the story. A brief author's note at the beginning provides some context for the family's forced migration, and indicates that the ending is intended to be hopeful, but it's difficult to identify any optimism here. The ending is abrupt and unsettling, with the girl gazing sadly back to where her dog was lost while the rest of the traveling party looks forward. The palette of the stylized watercolor illustrations shifts from yellows to blues in the last two pages, reinforcing the despondent mood. This stark picture book doesn't sugarcoat the challenges of forced migration: it is sad, with no sense of resolution. This straightforward approach can launch important conversations between adults and children about the circumstances in which a family might have to move, and the immense difficulties that can ensue. Whether beneficial as bibliotherapy for readers who have gone through similarly tumultuous situations, or as a way to build empathy for the hardships others have endured, this book may not find easily find its audience. The distressing ending and lack of explanatory detail make it unlikely as a first choice for introducing children to the concept of forced migration. VERDICT Therapeutic and thought-provoking for some young readers, possibly disturbing for others; purchase where migrant and refugee stories are in high demand. Allison Tran, Mission Viejo Lib., CA
Kirkus Reviews
Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)
School Library Journal (Wed Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2021)
Perfect for fans of Oliver Jeffers and Jon Klassen, this nearly wordless picture book tells a heartwarming and hopeful story of loss and new beginnings as a little girl and her dog, Antonia, journey with their family across a river to start a new life.
Like so many people around the world facing difficult times, the little girl and her family in this eye-catching and emotionally satisfying picture book have had to leave their home. The girl has brought along her belongings and her friendly, curious dog, Antonia. While waiting for a boat to take them across a river, she plays with other children who've also brought pets --a duck and a bird. But on the other side of the river, Antonia goes missing in the brush. The girl is distraught, until a new friend releases his own pet bird from its cage in an extraordinary gesture of solidarity and freedom. With colorful, whimsical illustrations and an uplifting message of resilience, this US debut from a talented Colombian creator will leave readers with a full heart.