ALA Booklist (Tue Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 1998)

Four voices in four seasons in a city park, each one is an ape in human clothing: a rich, uptight woman in the fall; a sad, unemployed man in the winter; the woman's lonely boy in the spring; the man's joyful daughter, Smudge, in the summer. Each in turn tells of a brief encounter with the others when they meet in the park with their dogs. Each one sees the place and the others differently; even the type font for each section is different, yet together the voices tell a story. As always, Browne's paintings extend the narrative with almost surreal details that could almost be true. In fall, the boy is overwhelmed by his domineering mom and sits obediently on the bench, except for a few snatched moments when he meets with Smudge in the distance; as his mom drags him away, an autumn tree is in flames like a lamp. In summer, he and Smudge play together and laugh in the light. There is no neat ending--the boy must return to his sad home--but everyone will recognize how a brief encounter with a stranger can give you a glimpse of possibilities. Kids who look closely will discover intense and playful details: a cross-hatched picture shows the boy shut in at home; in the park a classical statue scratches her neck and dangles her sunglasses. (Reviewed September 15, 1998)

Horn Book (Thu Apr 01 00:00:00 CST 1999)

Using four points of view, Browne explicitly contrasts the meaning of a particular event to its four participants. A gorilla takes her son Charles and dog Victoria to the park, where Victoria plays with a mutt belonging to another gorilla, who's searching for a job, and where Charles makes friends with his daughter Smudge. Browne's expressive and elegantly structured paintings are full of his usual surreal asides in this handsome, provocative book.

Kirkus Reviews

Browne's exceptional out-of-time story—about a visit to the neighborhood park by his familiar gorillas—is told from four perspectives. The first voice is that of a prim, supercilious mother, who has taken her son and pedigreed dog to the park for some air. She sees danger lurking in her charges' dealings with the great unwashed: her dog with a mongrel, her son with a ragamuffin. The second voice is careworn, but ultimately cheered by the visit; a jobless father takes his mutt and his daughter to the park for a break from his worries. Voice three is the first lady's son—hesitant and hemmed in—who finds a moment of liberation when playing with the jobless father's daughter. And lastly is that of the girl herself, a happy-go-lucky fixer-upper for all those who step into her radiance. This quartet of interpolating impressions has a cinematic quality, where real objects and their shadows often take separate paths. Browne's artwork is deft and kaleidoscopic, with sidelong imagery and a nod to RenC Magritte that heighten the surreal aspects of the story. (Picture book. 5-11)

School Library Journal

K-Gr 5-A mother takes her son and their dog to the park, where she thinks about dinner and turns up her nose at the "frightful types." Meanwhile, an unemployed father sits on the same bench and searches the want ads while admiring his daughter's chatter and their dog's energy. The two kids, of course, find one another. In four short first-person narratives, each of the characters recounts the same outing from a different perspective and at a different emotional level. The mother is annoyed. The father is melancholy. The boy is bored and lonely, then hopeful. The girl is independent and outgoing, yet observant. The real "voices," however, are not found in the quiet, straightforward text, but in Browne's vibrant, super-realistic paintings in which trees are oddly shaped, footsteps turn to flower petals, Santa Claus begs for change, and people happen to be primates. Some of the illustrations appear in smaller squares while others are full bleeds so that even the margins become part of the narrative. Browne's fans should find this even more satisfying than Willy the Dreamer (Candlewick, 1998). Because readers will want to compare pages (did that building turn into a castle?) and tarry over every detail, this book is best suited to independent reading. Even prereaders will be intrigued by the way a simple visit to the park can literally be "seen" in so many different ways.-Nina Lindsay, Oakland Public Library, CA