ALA Booklist (Sun Feb 01 00:00:00 CST 2009)

The lovable but insecure feline from Splat the Cat (2008) returns to celebrate Valentine's Day. He has a crush on Kitten, but whenever they meet she pulls his ears, ties his tail, and calls him smelly. His classmate Spike o has his own crush on Kitten es his best to convince Splat that Kitten doesn't return his affections. Fortunately, Kitten is able to see through Spike's amorous professions, leading to a happy Valentine exchange. Scotton's cartoon-style artwork features animals rendered in black-and-gray tones using vividly colored human accessories. A perfect choice for Valentine story hours or for Splat fans any time of the year.

Horn Book (Sat Aug 01 00:00:00 CDT 2009)

Lovesick Splat makes a special valentine for Kitten, even though she "pulled his ears and poked his belly, tied his tail and called him smelly"--and has another admirer named Spike. Satisfyingly, Kitten gives a lovely card to Splat, too. In Scotton's cartoon illustrations, the fuzzy black cat and his homemade card evoke all the highs and lows of Valentine's Day.

School Library Journal (Sun Mar 01 00:00:00 CST 2009)

K-Gr 2 In this follow-up to Splat the Cat (HarperCollins, 2008), the fuzzy black feline learns that bigger isn't better when it comes to Valentine's Day cards. Splat has a crush on Kitten, a fluffy white cat with pea-green eyes, but he isn't the only one. Self-assured Spike informs Splat that he likes her much more and has prepared a superior Valentine to prove it. Discouraged, Splat tosses his tribute into the trash. Kitten smiles as she receives Spike's card but doesn't swoon as she reads, "You are so lucky that I like you." Happily, she notices the little red envelope in the trash and surprises Splat with a pink Valentine that leaves him grinning from ear to ear. The cartoon-style illustrations have a contemporary, quirky feel due to the monochromatic palette, which is punctuated with brightly colored details. Children will giggle at Splat's awkward interactions with Kitten and smile at the story's satisfying conclusion. Lisa Glasscock, Columbine Public Library, Littleton, CO