ALA Booklist (Tue Nov 01 00:00:00 CDT 2022)

When Ashana meets Poppy, she falls rd. This is her first big love; she's been toyed with and left behind so many times before that it doesn't really seem real. But then, after narrowly avoiding accidents so many times it borders on funny, Ashana dies. And as the last person to die on New Year's Eve, she becomes a grim reaper, destined to forever take people's souls and lead them to Charon the ferryman. Though she occasionally comforts the dying, Ash always muses about the people she's collecting, who they once were, and if they once were like her and Poppy. But one day, she actually sees Poppy, and Poppy can see her, too ich means that Poppy is going to die soon. While the opening chapter gives clues as to what's going to happen to Ash, the following chapters, labeled "Before," take a little while to really get going. But Byrne has a gift for prose, and Ash and Poppy's budding relationship is evocative of a real first love.

Kirkus Reviews

Not even death can stop the love between two 16-year-old girls in Brighton, England, when one becomes a grim reaper.Ashana Persaud, an Indo-Guyanese British girl, attends Whitehawk, a state school with a bad reputation. White redhead Poppy Morgan goes to posh Roedean. They meet when both are on school trips and hit it off right away, falling in love and planning their future. But when Ash dies on New Year's Eve, she transforms into a grim reaper, working alongside two other teenage grim reapers to lead newly departed souls to Charon and his boat. They must avoid anyone they knew when they were alive, and they can only be seen in their previous, living forms by people who are about to die. Ash desperately wants to see Poppy again, but when she finally does, Poppy recognizes her. Ash's new goal becomes to save Poppy from her impending fate even as the pair relish this second chance. The novel is split into two main sections, "Before" and "After." Both are compelling, although they feel disjointed as readers meet several new characters in the latter half while Ash's friends and family from the first part are sidelined. Still, it's the romance that drives the story, and Ash and Poppy are so full of heart. Their feelings for each other are big and overwhelming, and this is an endearing and realistic representation of first love.A heartfelt and emotional queer romance with a fresh paranormal twist. (Paranormal romance. 14-18)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

A teenager’s life—and budding romance—is unceremoniously cut short when she dies and becomes a grim reaper in this otherworldly romance by British author Byrne. Despite differing financial circumstances and their experiencing homophobia within their Brighton community, the attraction between Indo-

School Library Journal (Sun Jan 01 00:00:00 CST 2023)

Gr 9 Up —Ash Persaud has never been The One. The one that is smart. The one that gets the girl. The one who is enough. So when she meets Poppy Morgan on a school trip, she doesn't dare to hope that their instant attraction and flirtation will ever be anything more. But Poppy isn't afraid to be who she is, or with who she wants, and as their relationship develops, Ash begins to see a future of infinite possibility. Until tragedy steps in, and Ash, as the last person to die on New Year's Eve, finds herself inducted into a strange new world—the world of being a grim reaper. Faced with the finality of death, and after-death, Ash must decide if she can let go of everything she held dear, or if she's willing to pay the price of defiance. Byrne's book is a heavy hitter, with an emotional depth and complexity that will likely resonate well with its intended audience. The prose is beautifully written, lyrical but never purple, with only a few missteps in using a repetitive device too often. Well-crafted characters help carry readers through when the pacing abruptly jerks to halt with Ash's transition into grim reaperhood. Ash and her family are British-Guyanese, and have a strong connection with their West Indies community in Brighton. Supporting characters are described as Desi, Black, white, and unspecified. Ash's best friend Adara wears a hijab. VERDICT An excellent candidate for any library's teen collection, this is likely to appeal to a wide range of teen readers, with new adult and adult crossover appeal.—Chrystopher Lytal