Publisher's Hardcover ©2022 | -- |
Truthfulness and falsehood. Juvenile literature.
Deception. Juvenile literature.
Critical thinking. Juvenile literature.
Honesty.
Deception.
Critical thinking.
A book about public lies, the kind that "can destabilize the world."Deceit, says noted nonfiction writer Kurlansky, is practiced throughout the living world, often conferring evolutionary advantages, and certainly many social ones-consider the white lie. Three hundred years ago, the rise of the Enlightenment ushered in both a new era of scientific reason and a corresponding rise in lies and conspiracy theories promulgated by power-hungry individuals attempting to dupe the masses. Today's social media makes this ever more prevalent but also gives those who pay attention tools they can use to broadcast the truth. From murderous clowns to lizard people in government, burning women as witches to persistent scapegoating of Jews, Kurlansky covers the types, tools, targets, tactics, and motives of liars as well as arms readers with defensive techniques such as searching for sources and the classic advice to "follow the money." Supplemental stories are told in sidebars set off in orange type. Blocks of larger, colorful type break up the pages, as do occasional illustrations and photographs. Short comic-strip segments enliven the ends of each chapter, illustrating Soviet spies sowing anti-vaccine disinformation and showing a dishonest, bankrupt real estate investor denying climate change. This book takes on a dense and complicated subject; Kurlansky's genius is to embrace the complexity and urge readers to question everything they read, including this book.Impassioned, thorough, and brilliant: describes the struggle for truth that "keeps the world from descending into chaos." (photo credits, author's note, sources, index) (Nonfiction. 12-18)
Kirkus Reviews (Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)A book about public lies, the kind that "can destabilize the world."Deceit, says noted nonfiction writer Kurlansky, is practiced throughout the living world, often conferring evolutionary advantages, and certainly many social ones-consider the white lie. Three hundred years ago, the rise of the Enlightenment ushered in both a new era of scientific reason and a corresponding rise in lies and conspiracy theories promulgated by power-hungry individuals attempting to dupe the masses. Today's social media makes this ever more prevalent but also gives those who pay attention tools they can use to broadcast the truth. From murderous clowns to lizard people in government, burning women as witches to persistent scapegoating of Jews, Kurlansky covers the types, tools, targets, tactics, and motives of liars as well as arms readers with defensive techniques such as searching for sources and the classic advice to "follow the money." Supplemental stories are told in sidebars set off in orange type. Blocks of larger, colorful type break up the pages, as do occasional illustrations and photographs. Short comic-strip segments enliven the ends of each chapter, illustrating Soviet spies sowing anti-vaccine disinformation and showing a dishonest, bankrupt real estate investor denying climate change. This book takes on a dense and complicated subject; Kurlansky's genius is to embrace the complexity and urge readers to question everything they read, including this book.Impassioned, thorough, and brilliant: describes the struggle for truth that "keeps the world from descending into chaos." (photo credits, author's note, sources, index) (Nonfiction. 12-18)
Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)In this noteworthy guide to media literacy, Kurlansky (
Gr 7 Up— Kurlansky outlines the history of lying in this informative and compelling introduction to the topic, specifically focusing on the lies of governments, politicians, and corporations with a political agenda. He opens with a general introduction to lying: personal and public, intentional or not, as well as various reasons for lying and its acceptability. Particularly interesting is the discussion of the principles of the Enlightenment, how they influenced the U.S. Constitution, and how the aristocracy and state-supported religions made anti-Enlightenment arguments to remain in power. Subsequent chapters cover a wide variety of history including science denial, lies against women and religious groups, the Soviet Union's extreme use of lying, and lies of the U.S. government. Later chapters cover topics such as the manipulation of photographs. In all of these chapters, historical as well as modern examples are covered demonstrating that lying is nothing new, just the methods and speed of spreading them change. The final chapter gives readers techniques for detecting lies and ways to check the veracity of online statements. The engaging text will keep pages turning quickly along with breaks that highlight important statements using an extra-large eye-catching font, related pictures, humorous comic strips, and sidebars with interesting stories. The work is well-documented with extensive sources and an index. VERDICT Kurlansky advises readers "It would not be acceptable to call everyone a liar, but it is wise to question everything you are told." Libraries would be equally wise to purchase and recommend to middle and high school students.— Karen T. Bilton
Starred Review for Kirkus Reviews (Fri Sep 16 00:00:00 CDT 2022)
Starred Review for Publishers Weekly (Fri Sep 16 00:00:00 CDT 2022)
Kirkus Reviews (Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)
Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)
School Library Journal (Thu Dec 01 00:00:00 CST 2022)
Entreaty
" Truth tickles everyone's nostrils. The question is, how's it to be pulled from the heap? "
--Isaac Babel, "My First Goose" (a story in Red Cavalry, 1926)
This book is full of ideas, facts, and opinions. It would be easy just to read and believe it, but I ask you instead to consider as you read and to decide for yourself what to believe. Francis Bacon, a pioneer of the scientific method, wrote in 1612, "Read not to contradict and confute, nor to believe and take for granted, nor to find talk and discourse; but to weigh and consider."
That is how we struggle toward the truth, and it is that struggle that keeps the world from descending into chaos.
While it is often easy to spot a lie, it is harder to know what is true. Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, a still-admired nineteenth-century German philosopher, maintained that there is always an absolute truth, but it is not always possible to know it. That may be so, but the search for truth must be never-ending. We cannot achieve a well-ordered, healthy society for all the world's people if we do not keep asking what is true. Often the question is why so many people choose to believe obvious lies. No lie becomes a big lie--a lie that undermines freedom, humanity, and the common good--without willing believers. Belief is a choice, and honesty begins in each of us. It is all too human to prefer an attractive lie to an inconvenient truth requiring difficult changes. When a lie provides comfort, consolation, excuses, or permission to do what you'd like to do anyway, who wouldn't prefer it? It is harder to question everything, but democracy depends on moral courage, independent thinking, and fair-mindedness. A lack of caring what is true or false is the undoing of democracy. Hannah Arendt, who fled Hitler's Germany and became one of the great philosophers of the twentieth century, wrote in Origins of Totalitarianism, "The ideal subject of totalitarianism is not the convinced Nazi, or the dedicated communist, but the people for whom the distinction between fact and fiction, true and false, no longer exists."
I hope that you will keep asking yourself what is true as you read this book and live your life.
Excerpted from Big Lies: From Socrates to Social Media by Mark Kurlansky, Eric Zelz
All rights reserved by the original copyright owners. Excerpts are provided for display purposes only and may not be reproduced, reprinted or distributed without the written permission of the publisher.
Big lies are told by governments, politicians, and corporations to avoid responsibility, cast blame on the innocent, win elections, disguise intent, create chaos, and gain power and wealth. Big lies are as old as civilization. They corrupt public understanding and discourse, turn science upside down, and reinvent history. They prevent humanity from addressing critical challenges. They perpetuate injustices. They destabilize the world. The modern age has provided ever-more-effective ways of spreading lies, but it has also given us the scientific method, which is the most effective tool for finding what is true. In the book's final chapter, Kurlansky reveals ways to deconstruct an allegation. A scientific theory has to be testable, and so does an allegation. BIG LIES soars across history: alighting on the "noble lies" of Socrates and Plato; Nero blaming Christians for the burning of Rome; the great injustices of the Middle Ages; the big lies of Stalin and Hitler and their terrible consequences; the reckless lies of contemporary demagogues, which are amplified through social media; lies against women and Jews are two examples in the long history of "othering" the vulnerable for personal gain; up to the equal-opportunity spotlight in America. "Belief is a choice," Kurlansky writes, "and honesty begins in each of us. A lack of caring what is true or false is the undoing of democracy. The alternative to truth is a corrupt state in which the loudest voices and most seductive lies confer power and wealth on grifters and oligarchs. We cannot achieve a healthy planet for all the world's people if we do not keep asking what is true."