ALA Booklist
(Tue Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2008)
Since her parents divorced, when she was an infant, life has been split between them: "School days in the city with Mom / weekends on the farm with Dad." Even her names are different len with Mom; Jo with Dad. But as she turns 13, she's determined to be JoEllen, to show her city friends that the country is not "hick," and her farm cousin that the city holds more than "concrete and crime." Using free verse, Zimmer shows the richness in both places, while black-and-white composite illustrations bring the bits and pieces together om the baseball trophies in Dad's old room to the overview of city traffic. Casual and open, both the poetry and pictures show the fun: "With Dad, one thing's for certain; / nothing ever is."
Kirkus Reviews
Living separate lives to please her divorced parents, a young girl struggles to define herself. <p>Living separate lives to please her divorced parents, a young girl struggles to define herself. JoEllen's mother lives in a city apartment while her father lives 42 miles away in a farmhouse. JoEllen (named for both parents) admits "my days . . . are as different as my names." She spends schooldays with Mom, who calls her "Ellen," and weekends with Dad, who calls her "Joey." JoEllen and Mom love takeout. JoEllen and Dad invent their own recipes. In the city, JoEllen plays the sax, watches old movies, wears vintage clothing and works at a secondhand shop with her best friends. At the farm, she trail rides with her cousin, listens to bluegrass, wears work boots and slops out the stable. Split "like an apple's pale heart / on either side of the blade," JoEllen decides her two lives need to meet--just in time for her 13th birthday. Embellished with Clayton's scrapbook-like black-and-white illustrations, the free-verse text traces the hopes and fears of a thoughtful teen who optimistically merges the best of her two lives into an even better "new me." <i>(Fiction/poetry. 9-12)</i></p>
School Library Journal
(Tue Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2008)
Gr 5-8 Caught between her divorced parents' rural and city worlds, JoEllen approaches her 13th birthday with a growing definition and assurance of her personal identity. Half of her name is from her father, Joseph, who calls her Joey; the other half is from her mother, Eleanor, who calls her Ellen. "Now my days/divided between them/are as different as my names." The girl's life, however, at each end of the 42 miles that separate her parents, is rich and complicated, and the author subtly develops JoEllen's awareness: "The apple trees/share secrets./The ducks endlessly discuss/the quality of rain" ("Farm Nights"). "An ambulance wailing/cars cussing/cats calling/dogs delivering the news" ("Cincinnati Nights"). The poems meld together into a smooth story that ends with this invitation: "My favorite poems/hold a wooden spoon of words/and whisper:/Taste" ("The Poems I Like Best"). Mixed-media collage illustrations complement the subject of each poem and reinforce the complicated and changing moods of the story. Young people will appreciate this easy-to-read, empowering story. Lee Bock, Glenbrook Elementary School, Pulaski, WI