Perma-Bound Edition ©2023 | -- |
Library Binding (Large Print) ©2022 | -- |
Publisher's Hardcover ©2021 | -- |
Library Binding ©2021 | -- |
Paperback ©2023 | -- |
Starred Review Equal parts Western, ghost story, and mystery, Palacio's first novel outside of the Wonder universe presents the fantastical yet utterly believable tale of a 12-year-old boy's search for his kidnapped father. Silas, along with his invisible-to-others companion (Mittenwool) and a single-minded pony, journey together through a scary wood to save Silas' father from a gang of counterfeiters. Along the way, they partner with a cantankerous U.S. Marshall, who is also hot on the trail of the nefarious baddies. The soul of this rip-roaring adventure lies in the author's ability to draw significant connections and relationships among characters, between the past and the present, and with lost and displaced souls and their people. This metaphysical juxtaposition works all the way to the surprising final revelation. In addition to the writing, the amount of thought given to the physical presentation of the book is remarkable. Chapter frontispieces are daguerreotypes and ambrotypes of American Civil War era portraits. These are juxtaposed with contemporaneous quotations and the haunting lyrics of bygone songs that set a definite mood. Attention to detail extends even to the typefaces used, capturing the period feel. The author's note is wonderfully informative, explaining processes and histories. Pony illustrates Palacio's range as an author, with this tale being distinctly different from Wonder (2012) yet sharing movingly captured central themes of heart, family, and overcoming challenges. HIGH-DEMAND BACKSTORY: Wonder has become a modern classic; everyone will want to see what else Palacio can do.
Horn Book (Mon Feb 06 00:00:00 CST 2023)Twelve-year-old Silas Bird lives with his father, a bootmaker and photographer, outside Boneville, Ohio, in 1860. His mother died when he was born, but he does have another companion, a ghost named Mittenwool. When three armed riders show up and haul Pa away, claiming he is the infamous counterfeiter Mac Boat, Silas is lonely and lost, but when one of the men's horses returns -- a black horse with a bone-white face -- Silas determines to go after his father. Though Silas (well-versed in the classics) tries out names for the horse -- Bucephalus, Gringolet, Perceval -- the horse remains "Pony." Their journey after Pa is not to be taken lightly, as Mittenwool warns, and it involves traversing the ancient Woods, where they are engulfed by tangled branches and whispers and moans and air thick with words and ghosts (which Silas has the ability to see). Daguerreotypes begin each chapter, lending period appeal as well as extending the thematic thread of photography and counterfeiting. It becomes a hero's journey, on which Silas feels like Telemachus, a boy in search of his lost father. Classical allusions lend depth to Palacio's elegantly written tale. Telling the story from a perspective of years later allows for philosophical considerations, as Silas realizes "the invisible threads" that have bound him to his mother from the beginning. This is Palacio's first novel that doesn't involve characters from Wonder (2012), but it involves plenty of wonder, in rich and haunting ways. An informative and personal author's note is appended. Dean Schneider
Kirkus ReviewsA boy, accompanied by ghosts and a bald-faced pony, sets out to rescue his father.Silas Bird, 12, his father, a Scottish immigrant bootmaker and experimental photographer, and Mittenwool, a ghost only Silas can see, live near the fictional Ohio town of Boneville in 1860. One night, three armed strangers on horseback insist that Pa come do some sort of business with them. Pa promises he'll return in a week, but the next morning, when a pony one of the men was leading returns to the farm, Silas decides to ride after him, though it means braving the ancient and terrifying Woods, more ghosts, and his own fears. Palacio writes smoothly, with engaging details, but narrator Silas sometimes seems far younger than 12 and other times too adult. The presentation of the ghosts is also inconsistent: Some can see each other, others can't; Silas recognizes some as ghosts but thinks others are living people. A conversation between Silas and a White settler, following a scene in which Silas encounters the ghosts of Native people massacred by the U.S. government, plays into unfortunate tropes of Indian nations no longer existing. The eponymous Pony drives several plot points but doesn't come across as a real equine. Among other horse-related slip-ups, novice rider Silas manages a 12-hour day without either himself or the pony dropping from exhaustion. Atmospheric daguerreotypes front each chapter. All characters are White.Beautiful writing cannot compensate for weaknesses in worldbuilding. (author's note) (Historical fiction. 10-14)
Starred Review ALA Booklist (Thu Apr 28 00:00:00 CDT 2022)
Horn Book (Mon Feb 06 00:00:00 CST 2023)
Kirkus Reviews
Publishers Weekly (Tue Dec 03 00:00:00 CST 2024)
1
It was my bout with lightning that inspired Pa to become immersed in the photographic sciences, which is how this all began.
Pa had always had a natural curiosity about photography, having come from Scotland, where such arts flourish. He dabbled in daguerreotypes for a short while after settling in Ohio, a region naturally full of salt springs (from which comes the agent bromine, an essential component of the developing process). But daguerreotypes were an expensive enterprise that turned very little profit, and Pa did not have the means to pursue it. People haven't the money for delicate souvenirs, he reasoned. Which is why he became a boot-maker. People always have a need for boots, he said. Pa's specialty was the calf-high Wellington in grain leather, to which he added a secret compartment in the heel for the storing of tobacco or a pocketknife. This convenience was greatly desired by customers, so we got by pretty well on those boot orders. Pa worked in the shed next to the barn, and once a month traveled to Boneville with a cartful of boots pulled by Mule, our mule.
But after lightning imprinted my back with the image of the oak tree, Pa once again turned his attention to the science of photography. It was his belief that the image on my skin had come there as a consequence of the same chemical reactions at play in photography. The human body, he told me as I watched him mixing chemicals that smelled of rotten eggs and cider vinegar, is a vessel full of the same mysterious substances, subject to the same physical laws, as everything else in the universe. If an image can be preserved by the action of light upon your body, it can be preserved by the same action upon paper. That is why it was not daguerreotypes that drew his interest anymore, but a new form of photography involving paper soaked in a solution of iron and salt, to which is transferred, by means of sunlight, a positive image from a glass negative.
Pa quickly mastered the new science, and became a highly regarded practitioner of the collodion process, as it was called, an art form hardly seen in these parts. It was a bold field, requiring great experimentation, and resulting in pictures most astounding in their beauty. Pa's irontypes, as he called them, had none of the exactitude of daguerreotypes, but were imbued with subtle shadings that made them look like charcoal art. He used his own proprietary formula for the sensitizer, which is where the bromine came in, and applied for a patent before opening a studio in Boneville, down the road from the courthouse. In no time at all, his iron-dusted paper portraits became quite the rage around here, for not only were they infinitely cheaper than daguerreotypes, but they could be reproduced over and over again from a single negative. Adding even more to their allure, and for an extra charge, Pa would tint them with a mix of egg wash and colored pigment, which gave them a lifelike semblance most extraordinary to behold. People traveled from all over to have their portraits taken. One fancy lady came all the way from Akron for a sitting. I assisted in Pa's studio, adjusting the skylight and cleaning the focusing plates. A few times Pa even let me polish the new brass portrait lens, which had been a major investment in the business and required delicacy in its handling. Such had our circumstances turned, Pa's and mine, that he was contemplating selling his boot-making enterprise altogether, for he said he much preferred the smell of mixing potions to the stink of people's feet.
It was at this time that our lives were forever changed by the predawn visitation of three riders and a bald-faced pony.
2
Mittenwool was the one who roused me from my deep slumber that night.
"Silas, awake now. There are riders coming this way," he said.
I would be lying if I said I was jolted up right away, to my feet, by the urgency of his call. But I did no such thing. I simply mumbled something and turned in my bed. He nudged me hard then, which is not a simple feat for him. Ghosts do not easily maneuver in the material world.
"Let me sleep," I answered grumpily.
It was then that I heard Argos howling like a banshee downstairs, and Pa cock his rifle. I looked out the tiny window next to my bed, but it was a black-as-ink night and I could see nothing.
"There are three of them," said Mittenwool, squinting over my shoulder through the same window.
"Pa?" I called out, jumping down from the loft. He was ready, boots on, peering through the front window.
"Stay down, Silas," he cautioned.
"Should I light the lamp?"
"No. Did you see them from your window? How many are there?" he asked.
"I didn't see them myself, but Mittenwool says there are three of them."
"Guns drawn," Mittenwool added.
"They have their guns drawn," I said. "What do they want, Pa?"
Pa didn't answer. We could hear the galloping coming toward us now. Pa cracked the front door open, rifle at the ready. He threw on his coat and turned to look at me.
"You don't come out, Silas. No matter what," he said, his voice stern. "If there's trouble, you run over to Havelock's house. Out the back through the fields. You hear me?"
"You're not going out there, are you?"
"Get ahold of Argos," he answered. "Don't let him out."
I collared Argos. "You're not going out there, are you?" I asked again, frightened.
He did not stop to answer me but opened the door and ventured out to the porch, aiming his rifle toward the approaching riders. He was a brave man, my pa.
I pulled Argos close to me and then crept over to the front window and peeked out. I saw the men advance. Three riders, just like Mittenwool had said. Behind one of them trailed a fourth horse, a giant black charger, and next to it, the pony with a bone-white face.
The horsemen slowed down as they approached the house, in deference to Pa's rifle. The leader of the three, a man in a yellow duster on a spotted horse, put his arms up in the air in a peaceful gesture as he brought his steed to a full stop.
"Ho there," he said to Pa, not forty feet from the porch. "You can put down your weapon, mister. I come in peace."
"Put yours down first," Pa answered, his rifle shouldered.
"Mine?" The man looked theatrically at his own empty hands, and then left and right, making a show of only now noting his companions' drawn weapons. "Put those down, boys! You're making a bad impression." He turned back to Pa. "Sorry about that. They mean no harm. Just force of habit."
"Who are you?" Pa said.
"Are you Mac Boat?"
Pa shook his head. "Who are you? Come storming here in the middle of the night."
The yellow-duster man did not seem afraid of Pa's rifle in the least. I could not see him well in the dark, but I judged him to be smaller than Pa (Pa being one of the tallest men in Boneville). Younger, too. He wore a derby hat like gentlemen do, but he wasn't one, as far as I could see. He looked a ruffian. Pointy-bearded.
"Now, now, don't get riled," he said, his voice light. "My boys and I meant to arrive at sunup, but we made better time than we thought. I'm Rufe Jones, and these here are Seb and Eben Morton. Don't bother trying to tell them apart, it's impossible." It was only then that I noted the two hulking men were exact duplicates of each other, wearing identical melon hats with wide bands down low over their moon-round faces. "We've come here with an interesting proposition from our boss, Roscoe Ollerenshaw. You heard of him, I'm sure?"
Pa made no response to that.
"Well, Mr. Ollerenshaw knows of you, Mac Boat," Rufe Jones continued.
"Who is Mac Boat?" Mittenwool whispered to me.
"I don't know any Mac Boat," Pa said from behind his rifle. "I am Martin Bird."
"Of course," Rufe Jones answered quickly, nodding. "Martin Bird, the photographer. Mr. Ollerenshaw's very familiar with your work! That's why we're here, you see. He has a business proposition he'd like to discuss with you. We've come a long way to talk with you. Might we come inside for a bit? We've been riding all night. My bones are chilled." He raised the collar on his duster to illustrate the point.
"If you want to talk business, you come to my studio in the daylight hours like any civilized man would," Pa said.
"Now, why would you adopt that tone with me?" Rufe Jones asked, as if perplexed. "The nature of our business requires some privacy, is all. We mean you no harm, not you or your boy, Silas. That's him hovering by the window behind you, right?"
I swallowed hard, I'm not going to lie, and pulled my head back from the window. Mittenwool, who was behind me, nudged me to crouch down farther.
"You have five seconds to get off my property," Pa warned, and I could tell from his voice he meant it.
But Rufe Jones must not have heard the threatening tone in Pa's words, for he laughed. "Now, now, don't get vexed. I'm just the messenger here!" he replied calmly. "Mr. Ollerenshaw sent us to come get you, and that's what we're doing. Like I said, he means you no harm. In fact, he wants to help you. He wanted me to tell you there's a lot of money in it for you. A small fortune were his exact words. For very little inconvenience on your part. Just a week's work and you'll be a rich man. We even brought you horses to ride! A nice big one for you, and a fetching little one for your boy. Mr. Ollerenshaw is something of a horse collector, so you should consider it an honor that he's letting you ride his fine steeds."
"I'm not interested. You now have three seconds to leave," answered Pa. "Two . . ."
"All right, all right!" said Rufe Jones, waving his hands in the air. "We'll leave. Don't you worry! Come on, fellas."
He pulled on his horse's reins and circled around, as did the brothers, wheeling the two riderless horses behind them. They started slow-walking into the night away from the house. But after a few steps, Rufe Jones stopped. He held his arms out to his sides, crucifixion-like, to show he was still unarmed. Then he looked over his shoulder at Pa.
"But we'll only come back tomorrow," he said, "with a lot more men. Mr. Ollerenshaw is not one to give up easily, truth be told. I came in peace tonight, but I can't promise it'll be the same tomorrow. Mr. Ollerenshaw, well, he wants what he wants."
"I'll get the sheriff involved," threatened Pa.
"Will you, Mr. Boat?" said Rufe Jones. His voice sounded more menacing now. It had none of the previous lightness.
"The name is Bird," answered Pa.
"Right. Martin Bird, the photographer of Boneville, who lives way out in the middle of nowhere with his son, Silas Bird."
"You best get," rasped Pa.
"All right," answered Rufe Jones. But he didn't spur his horse.
I was watching all this breathless, Mittenwool right next to me. A few seconds passed. No one moved or said a word.
3
"Here's the problem," said Rufe Jones, his arms still out at his sides. The singsong lilt returned to his voice. "It's a bother, our going all the way back across these fields, through the Woods, only to come back tomorrow with a dozen more of us, armed to the teeth. Lord knows what can happen with all those guns pointing every which way. You know how it goes. Tragedies can befall. But if you come with us tonight, Mr. Boat, we can avoid all that nasty business."
He flipped his hands over, so the palms faced up now.
"Let's not draw this out," he continued. "You and your boy will have a nice jolly ride with us on those fine horses. And we'll have you both back here in a week. That's a solemn promise from the big man himself. He told me to tell you that exactly, by the way. To use the word solemn. Come on, this is a good business proposition for you, Mac Boat! What do you say?"
I saw Pa, his rifle still trained on the man, his finger still on the trigger, clench his jaw. His expression was foreign to me at that moment. I did not recognize the taut angles of his body.
"I am not Mac Boat," he said slowly. "I am Martin Bird."
"Yes, of course, Mr. Bird! My apologies," replied Rufe Jones, grinning. "Whatever your name is, what do you say? Let's avoid any nastiness. Put your rifle down and come with us. It's only a week. And you'll return a rich man."
Pa hesitated for another long second. It felt to me like all of time was contained inside that moment. And it was, in a way, for it was inside that moment that my life was forever altered. Pa lowered his gun.
"What's he doing?" I whispered to Mittenwool. I was suddenly more scared than I recall ever being before. It was as if my heart had stopped. Like the world had ceased its breathing.
"All right, I'll go with you," Pa said quietly, breaking the stillness of the night like a thunderclap, "but only if you leave my boy out of it. He stays right here, safe and sound. He won't breathe a word of this to anybody. Nobody comes around here anyway. And I'm back here in a week. You said I have Ollerenshaw's solemn word. Not a day longer."
"Hmm, I don't know," Rufe Jones grumbled, shaking his head. "Mr. Ollerenshaw said to bring the two of you back with us. He was very specific about that."
"Like I said," answered Pa, his voice resolute, "it's the only way I'll go with you peacefully tonight. Otherwise, it will become nasty business, whether it's here and now or whenever you turn up again. I'm a good shot. Don't test me."
Rufe Jones took his derby off and rubbed his forehead. He looked at his two companions, but they said nothing, or perhaps they shrugged. It was hard to see anything in the darkness but their flat pale faces.
"Fine, fine, we'll keep it peaceful, then," Rufe Jones agreed. "Just you it is. But it's got to be now. Toss your gun over here. Let's be done with this."
"You can have it when we get to the Woods, not before."
Excerpted from Pony by R. J. Palacio
All rights reserved by the original copyright owners. Excerpts are provided for display purposes only and may not be reproduced, reprinted or distributed without the written permission of the publisher.
Instant New York Times Bestseller
The bestselling author of Wonder returns with an unforgettable adventure about a boy on a quest to rescue his father, with only a ghost as his companion and a mysterious pony as his guide.
When Silas Bird wakes in the dead of night, he watches powerlessly as three strangers take his father away. Silas is left shaken, scared, and alone, except for the presence of his companion, Mittenwool . . . who happens to be a ghost.
But then a mysterious pony shows up at his door, and Silas knows what he has to do.
So begins a perilous journey to find his father--a journey that will connect him with his past, his future, and the unknowable world around him.
R. J. Palacio spins a powerful and heartwarming story, one of those rare books destined to become a classic, beloved for generations to come.