ALA Booklist (Wed Sep 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

This fictional picture book based on a true story follows a group of Thai boys who love football erican soccer t have no place to play. In order to get better and compete with teams on the mainland, they need a place to practice. Since their village is predominantly on stilts, they have to get creative, and they eventually build a floating pitch on the water, despite the doubts of their neighbors. Told in quick-moving prose that evokes movement and sound, this story is coupled with crisp illustrations that match the spirit and the straightforward action of the text. The boys of Koh Panyee, while only slightly visually distinct from one another on the page, invite the reader to think about the lengths to which people can go to make their dreams come true. An author's note about the real village will hopefully encourage further research, while the heart of the story is sure to capture the imagination of the reader. A great read-alike for Julie Abery and Chris Sasaki's Sakamoto's Swim Club (2021).

Kirkus Reviews

Kids make their dreams come true.A group of boys who live in Koh Panyee, a small Thai village raised above the water on stilts, are obsessed with football (what Americans would refer to as soccer). They "dribble…on the way to school" and even shoot "goals during evening chores." On Saturday afternoons, they go to Uncle Hemmin's cafe to watch football, cheering for every goal. Inspired, the friends want to practice so they can eventually challenge the boys who live on the mainland, but they don't have anywhere to play. The evenly paced narrative reveals that every alleyway, pier, and walkway is already filled with busy adults with little patience for their ball playing. Even Uncle Hemmin tells them to "Stick to boat racing. It's tradition." A secret beach during low tide becomes their makeshift field until it is used for new homes. Frustrated, the boys decide to build their own floating pitch, hauling wood scraps and collecting nails and ignoring the laughter from villagers. Phumiruk creates dreamy scenes with soft hues of color to depict the boys slipping and falling into the water as they gradually improve their balance with their new and constantly "swaying pitch." Their hard work pays off, as the team performs well at a mainland football tournament, in the process winning over the hearts of their village-and readers. An author's note describes the real events that inspired this tale. (This book was reviewed digitally.)A stirring story of perseverance. (illustrator's note) (Picture book. 5-9)

School Library Journal (Sat Jul 01 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

Gr 2–4— In Koh Panyee, a village on stilts in Thailand's Phang Nga Bay, a group of boys shares a love for football (soccer in the U.S.). Playing football in a floating village is nigh impossible. Even as the whole village makes fun of them, the boys build a floating soccer pitch. With practice, they're able to compete in a real tournament on dry land. Only after witnessing their success do the boys' families and neighbors stop ridiculing them. Based on a true story, this is a charming if wordy tale of perseverance. Many pages feature multiple sentences or paragraphs spread across the page. Dialogue, ellipses, italics, and words in all uppercase create a complex reading experience for an otherwise simple story. The digital artwork is colorful but lacks depth. Characters are flat and there is no discernible light source in most illustrations. Bodies sometimes feature elongated limbs and awkward poses that make football scenes feel static. However, the scenes depicted enrich the text by providing readers with more information. Backgrounds are colorful and attractive. Back matter includes notes from the author and illustrator. VERDICT Recommended only for large collections.— Chance Lee Joyner