Starred Review ALA Booklist (Mon Nov 06 00:00:00 CST 2023)

Starred Review A week after his father's funeral, a Black boy opens the envelope that his father left for him and finds a map showing the nearby woods. In one spot is a red X. Does it mark a treasure? He and his father frequently walked those woods together, and he feels reluctant to go alone, but he does. Noticing a garter snake and an eagle along the way, he follows the paths to the spot and finds a rusted metal box containing sketches of woodland wildlife, with an unfinished story beneath each drawing. His father created both the sketches and the writings as a boy. On the last page, he invites his son to finish the stories and to draw and write his own. The back matter tells of the book's creation. Grimes and Jerry Pinkney decided to collaborate on a book in which Black characters engage with nature. Grimes wrote the free verse text, which tells the story concisely, while expressing the boy's shifting emotions beautifully. Before his death in 2021, Jerry Pinkney finished the detailed, engaging drawings, which reflect his love for the natural world. Afterwards, his son Brian Pinkney was asked to add the watercolor washes, which have a distinctive, ethereal quality that enhances the story. An original, inspiring picture book.

Starred Review for Kirkus Reviews (Wed Sep 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

A multilayered tale of loss.A Black boy opens an envelope from his recently deceased father and finds a treasure map marked with a red X. Disappointed his dad hasn't left him a letter, the boy puts on his hiking boots and reluctantly enters the woods. As he walks along the Hudson, he sees animals and notices reminders of the Mohicans, the original inhabitants of this land. Entering the ruins of a house, he finds a metal box in the brick fireplace and opens it with a key that has mysteriously appeared in his pocket. Inside, he finds a treasure trove of drawings of the natural world and an invitation to honor his father's artistic legacy. Grimes' quiet yet potent verse captures not only the boy's loss, but also the memories his father has left behind. In a moving author's note, she discusses her decadeslong friendship with Jerry Pinkney, who completed sketches for the book before he died in 2021; in an illustrator's note, Brian Pinkney describes how he completed the artwork and explains that this story mirrors his own experience of grappling with his father's death. Brian's stunning, opalescent watercolors closely resemble Jerry's but include the circular patterns and movement characteristic of his own illustrations. Together, Grimes and the Pinkneys have produced a profoundly stirring and thought-provoking musing on how the ones we love never really leave us. (This book was reviewed digitally.)Joy and hope walk alongside sadness and grief in this unforgettable work. (Picture book. 4-10)

School Library Journal Starred Review (Fri Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

Gr 1–4 —Grimes writes a heartrending story of loss as a young boy struggles to deal with the death of his father. When the child looks in the mirror, he is disheartened by what he sees—he is all but a replica of his father who has recently died. His father has left him a map of the woods behind their home with a red mark. He decides to take a walk in the woods, which he and his father did regularly. He begins to have an inner dialogue with his dad about the wildlife he sees and hears, and when he finds the place that is marked on the map, he sees a brick fireplace where a house once stood. Inside a metal box are beautiful drawings of wildlife and an unfinished tale. He realizes that his father created the drawings and the story when he was the boy's age, and the child finds a note from his father encouraging him to continue the story or write his own. This poignant story, obviously amplified by the passing of Jerry Pinkney, is quietly haunting and resonates with the shared experiences of parent and child. There is a third Pinkney involved, Charnelle Pinkney Barlow, who worked with Brian Pinkney to digitally combine Jerry's sketches with his own impressionistic applications of color. VERDICT Illustrations and narrative are warp and weft in a beautifully crafted story of grief and triumph. Great for any children's collection.—Annmarie Braithwaite

Horn Book (Thu Sep 07 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

Shortly after his father's death, a boy opens an envelope his father left him to find a map of the woods with a bright red X marking a destination. Still coping with his loss, he sets out on the path he and his father had taken on their walks through the woods near home. Along the way, the familiarity of trees, creatures, and a Mohican water storage house softens his sorrow while he reminisces about their conversations. At the marked spot, he discovers a metal box filled with sketches of wildlife and unfinished stories created by his father when he was the boy's age. The last page is blank with a note to the boy: "Draw and write your own story. I'll always be watching." Grimes's celebration of nature is as eloquent as her treatment of loss is poignant. Brian Pinkney's watercolor illustrations are equally expressive. This book began as a collaboration between Grimes and Jerry Pinkney; following Jerry's death in 2021, Brian joined Grimes to complete his father's illustrations, adding color to Jerry's tight sketches. Appended notes from Grimes and Brian Pinkney share their respective personal experiences with the collaboration. A touching testament to the power of memories to sustain those in grief. Pauletta Brown Bracy

Kirkus Reviews (Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)

A multilayered tale of loss.A Black boy opens an envelope from his recently deceased father and finds a treasure map marked with a red X. Disappointed his dad hasn't left him a letter, the boy puts on his hiking boots and reluctantly enters the woods. As he walks along the Hudson, he sees animals and notices reminders of the Mohicans, the original inhabitants of this land. Entering the ruins of a house, he finds a metal box in the brick fireplace and opens it with a key that has mysteriously appeared in his pocket. Inside, he finds a treasure trove of drawings of the natural world and an invitation to honor his father's artistic legacy. Grimes' quiet yet potent verse captures not only the boy's loss, but also the memories his father has left behind. In a moving author's note, she discusses her decadeslong friendship with Jerry Pinkney, who completed sketches for the book before he died in 2021; in an illustrator's note, Brian Pinkney describes how he completed the artwork and explains that this story mirrors his own experience of grappling with his father's death. Brian's stunning, opalescent watercolors closely resemble Jerry's but include the circular patterns and movement characteristic of his own illustrations. Together, Grimes and the Pinkneys have produced a profoundly stirring and thought-provoking musing on how the ones we love never really leave us. (This book was reviewed digitally.)Joy and hope walk alongside sadness and grief in this unforgettable work. (Picture book. 4-10)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

In an elegantly collaborative picture book about how “there’s always something that remains,” Grimes (Bedtime for Sweet Creatures), the late Jerry Pinkney (The Lion and the Mouse), and Brian Pinkney (Hey Otter! Hey Beaver!) center a grieving Black narrator following his beloved father’s death. A week after the funeral, the child, questioning aloud (“Why did you have to leave?”), opens an envelope left behind and finds a map of the nearby woods that he and his dad often explored—“with a marked spot shouting in bright red: ‘TREASURE.’ ” Emotions run high as the child heads to the woods, encountering memories and remaining alert to changing elements. “With each step, the hurt inside my heart pounds less.” Arriving at the marked spot, he finds a locked box, and inside, a sheaf of illustrations and poems about woodland animals—all created by his father at the child’s age, and all revealed in detail for the reader. Meditatively commanding text accompanies structural sketches that Jerry Pinkney completed before his death as well as loose, forest-hued wash overlays from Brian Pinkney. It’s a powerfully layered call to creativity and loving bonds that endure beyond death: “I close my eyes, and feel Dad next to me, his hand on my shoulder, light as leaves.” Creators’ notes conclude. Ages 4–8. Author’s agent: Elizabeth Harding, Curtis Brown. Illustrator’s agent: (for Jerry Pinkney) Sheldon Fogelman, Sheldon Fogelman Agency; (for Brian Pinkney) Rebecca Sherman, Writers House. (Sept.)