Publisher's Hardcover ©2024 | -- |
Koh-i-noor (Diamond). History. Juvenile literature.
Diamonds. India. History. Juvenile literature.
Crown jewels. Great Britain. History. Juvenile literature.
Colonization. Juvenile literature.
Koh-i-noor (Diamond). History.
Diamonds. India. History.
Crown jewels. Great Britain. History.
Colonization.
India. Colonization. Juvenile literature.
India. History. Juvenile literature.
Great Britain. History. Juvenile literature.
India. Colonization.
India. History.
Great Britain. History.
Starred Review A large diamond emerges from a riverbed in what is now India. It becomes a part of the Peacock Throne until it is looted by warriors who cart it and countless other treasures off to Iran. Many years later, it returns to India (now under British colonial rule), where it remains until its young keeper is tricked out of ownership, sending it to Britain, where it resides today as part of the crown jewels. Kelkar's lyrical telling makes clear the dire results of colonial oppression. Unspeakable things happen to this jewel (Britain's Prince Albert has it recut and shaped to adhere to Western standards of beauty, reducing its size by half), but, throughout, the diamond shines. Digitally enhanced cut-paper collage artwork dazzles the eye, from the teal-and-blue endpapers containing remnants of the gem's history, to the gleaming treasure whose light shines brightly, to depictions of other jewels with which it has shared company. Particularly impressive is an image of the sparkling marvel centered atop symbolic representations of its history. The back matter (containing a concise history, a definition of colonization, suggestions for decolonizing, and a discussion of stolen museum treasures) will be extremely helpful to adults sharing this story and those wishing to delve deeper. A gem not to be missed.
School Library Journal Starred Review (Wed May 01 00:00:00 CDT 2024)K-Gr 4 —In a second-person narrative of short, lyrical sentences, Kelkar relates the journey of the magnificent Kohinoor Diamond from the sediment in South Asia to a place of pride in the Peacock Throne, and then into a saga of theft on theft and literal degradation at the demands of Queen Victoria's husband, Prince Albert, going from over 190 carats to 93 because it is "not enough." In an author's note, readers learn of the shocking aftermath of the gem's journey: to this day, it is part of England's jewel stash in the Tower of London and it was said that Camilla, queen consort, planned to wear it at Charles's coronation before media attention pointed out its status as stolen goods. Exquisite illustrations of doe-eyed children and adults with brown skin were created from cut paper and materials such as metals, beads, gems, fabrics, and more, all assembled into collage by hand or digitally. Whether moodily atmospheric, haunted by the actions of colonizers, or melancholy with loss, the scenes convey the emotions of Kelkar's text, which returns to "And yet you shine" as both mantra and mandate—the diamond is still here, and history is no longer on the side of the thieves. Back matter, beyond the long and worthwhile author's note, includes further reading, bibliography, and study questions (for example, the complications of returning stolen artifacts even though keeping them is also abhorrent). VERDICT Share the book by inverting it; the author's note will settle children into a wicked and relevant history lesson. As lyrical as the light verse telling is, children need this context urgently to appreciate the beauty of the message.—Ginnie Abbott
Kirkus ReviewsAn account of the many lives of India's Kohinoor diamond."A pair of brown hands" extract the fabled diamond from a river. The stone eventually becomes part of "the Peacock Throne," finds its way onto an unnamed conqueror's arm, and passes to a series of other unknown owners until it returns "back home- / the land where those brown hands / first unearthed you." The diamond ends up in the custody of a 10-year-old boy-"scared and alone, / forcibly separated from his mother"-who is tricked into signing it away to a white man, presumably a British colonizer. Cut down much smaller than its original size, the diamond is embossed onto a British crown-a literal jewel in the crown. Why does the diamond shine throughout these trials and tribulations? The book's narrator-who addresses the story to the diamond-ultimately concludes that it's because the stone perceives its true worth. The collage illustrations are absolutely stunning, incorporating vibrant textures and colors that let this work sparkle like the titular diamond. The lyrical text is inspiring, and the use of second person is effective. The story's lack of specificity, however, adds an ambiguity that detracts somewhat from its emotional resonance; readers will need to consult the thorough backmatter to learn, for instance, that in 1628, Mughal emperor Shah Jahan had the Kohinoor diamond set in a throne shaped like peacocks.The mesmerizing visuals will enchant, but the text will keep many readers at arm's length. (further reading, bibliography) (Informational picture book. 7-12)
Starred Review ALA Booklist (Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)
School Library Journal Starred Review (Wed May 01 00:00:00 CDT 2024)
Kirkus Reviews
The story of one of the world’s most famous diamonds—stolen from South Asia during colonization and now among the crown jewels in London—is a call to action for readers to decolonize and hold their heads high.
The Kohinoor diamond, one of the most famous diamonds in the world, was stolen from India and fought over throughout centuries of colonial conquest, eventually landing in the hands of British royals who tricked a ten-year-old South Asian monarch into relinquishing it. The diamond was ultimately cut to nearly half its size to suit British beauty standards for the crown jewels—and is displayed to this day in the Tower of London museum, a trophy of colonization. Probing, poetic, and shimmering with the colors and patterns of Indian textiles, And Yet You Shine is more than the true story of a precious gem passing hands. The urgent narrative and well-researched afterword invite readers to consider the origins of museum artifacts and all they represent, how history is recorded, and why acknowledging past injustices and power dynamics can shape the world we live in today—and ensure a just tomorrow. This vibrant and moving meditation on resiliency invites readers of all backgrounds to decolonize—and shine with all their might.