Kirkus Reviews
(Mon Nov 06 00:00:00 CST 2023)
Vargas adapts Medina's Pura Belpré Award winner into graphic-novel form.Piedad Maria Sanchez, Piddy for short, is starting sophomore year at a new school in Queens while her best friend, Mitzi, is off to school in Long Island. Piddy is Cuban and Dominican, but she struggles to find a place with her Latine peers in her new school. In fact, Yaqui Delgado wants to kick her ass; as Piddy says, "I don't fit her idea of a Latina at all." Though Piddy tries to keep her head down and avoid confrontation, the bullying at school continues to escalate from threats and misogynistic name-calling to being jumped by a group of girls on her way home. Living with constant anxiety takes its toll on Piddy: She pushes away her mom and Mitzi and even ponders dropping out of school altogether to escape her tormentors. Readers will find themselves in turns rooting for Piddy and frustrated by her choices. In each of her relationships, Piddy learns how secrets can fester and that intimacy and trust are built through transparency. This graphic adaptation is a fast-paced page-turner. Vargas keeps the text to a minimum and communicates much of Piddy's inner turmoil wordlessly, proving the effectiveness of this format. The panels, illustrated in blue, gray, black, and white, have clean, minimalist backgrounds, putting the people and their emotions front and center.A decade on, as relevant as ever and likely to capture the hearts of even more readers. (Graphic fiction. 14-18)
School Library Journal
(Tue Aug 01 00:00:00 CDT 2023)
Gr 8 Up— Things are quickly changing for 10th grader Piddy Sanchez. When a dilapidated apartment building's unsafe conditions prompt Piddy's mom to move the two of them to a new home, a new school comes with it. Not only that, Piddy's best friend Mitzi has left the neighborhood for Long Island, and for some reason Piddy can't understand, Yaqui Delgado wants to kick her ass. As the unwanted attention from Yaqui escalates, Piddy begins to lose more and more of herself as she struggles with how best to address it. Domestic abuse and bullying are incorporated into the story, with the former never made visible to readers while the latter is, in the form of physical assault against Piddy on behalf of Yaqui and her friends. Punching, hair pulling, kicking, scratching, and removal of clothing is depicted over two spreads, as is cyber-bullying, when a video of the incident is shown to have been posted online. Despite the depiction of physical violence, the majority of the story is spent addressing the mental and emotional toll of the bullying. A minimalist color palette consisting of cornflower blue, black, white, and grays reflects the weight and solemnity of Piddy's difficulties while also softening some of the severity of her experiences. Piddy is Cuban and Dominican, family friend Lila appears Black, and a background character is seen wearing a hijab. Untranslated Spanish is sprinkled throughout, and the preface includes an author's note. VERDICT A carefully and skillfully approached, modernized adaptation that is sure to introduce Piddy and provide understanding to a new crop of teen readers.— Alea Perez