School Library Journal Starred Review
(Mon Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2024)
Gr 4–7— How do you describe an adventure involving two siblings who are complete opposites? In a "he said, she said" flip book written by real-life siblings Pangburn and Shearer! Older sister Nan is tall, neat, and wants to be a travel writer just like Mom. Younger brother Otto is short, stocky, messy, and more interested in comics and art camp than a trip to Egypt. The action takes place as they visit a pyramid for their mother's job. Otto sees the ghosts of a pharaoh and his mummified cat, but Nan doesn't believe him because they don't appear to her. First, readers experience Otto's POV as he tries to deal with these ghostly apparitions, and then they see Nan bewildered by Otto talking to thin air. The illustration style for each half matches the personality of the character whose viewpoint readers are experiencing. Otto's version has rounded edges and silliness in each scene, much like the "Cat Knight and Dog Woman" comics he draws. Nan's version matches her idea of herself as a no-nonsense reporter with straight edges, a slightly sinister ambiance, and reinforces Otto's younger age by always showing him down below Nan's eye level. VERDICT The perfect family vacation story, complete with mummies, newfound friends, and (eventually) sibling cooperation.— Suzanne Costner
Kirkus Reviews
During a trip to Egypt, two American siblings learn about an unfamiliar culture and stumble upon mummies in Pangburn and Shearer's middle-grade graphic novel.Eleven-year-old Nan and her little brother, Otto, are joining their travel-blogging mother on her latest voyage, whether they like it or not. Otto certainly doesn't, as the last-minute trip forces him to leave his beloved art camp early. But Nan, an aspiring travel blogger herself, is excited to witness Egypt's beauty and learn its history. The kids explore on their own, although Nan finds it hard to enjoy the experience when her brother runs off without her. As it happens, Otto is chasing after Princess Tiaa, a mummified cat who sprints outside her pyramid, and away from the cat's human mummy owner. It turns out that only Otto can see the mummies, who are invisible to Nan; however, he needs Nan's help sneaking back into the pyramid at night with the cat, where they deal with unexpected turns of events. Authors Pangburn and Shearer, who are siblings, present this story from dual perspectives; readers of the print copy must flip the book over for the second half. Otto opens the narrative, and he's a mostly endearing boy-even when he's whining-who craves adventure but shirks responsibility. The mummy-free, Nan-centric half, while less exhilarating, enriches the character of the dependable sister, as readers learn why a bracelet is so important to her and witness moments when she understandably tunes out her grumbling brother. There's relatively little overlap between the two stories, as the siblings are separated for a time. However, humor abounds, as when Otto converses with a seemingly empty sarcophagus in Nan's story, and there are copious educational tidbits on ancient and contemporary Egyptians. Touris' cartoon-style art bursts with color during Egypt's amber-tinted days and blue-gray nights. Illustration highlights include pages of Otto's own ongoing comic-book project featuring Cat Knight and Dogwoman, and Nan's journal of photos and sketches.A fun, illuminating tale with a wonderfully zippy cast.