Publisher's Hardcover ©2024 | -- |
The sudden loss of her closest friend leaves a child clinging desperately to memories and connections.Deep in denial, Ayla is sure that though her lifelong bestie "went away," Kiri (who used they/them pronouns) will be back in time for their 11th birthday. But, as gradually becomes clear, "went away" means more than just a temporary absence. Cast in half-page prose poems, this grief journal sensitively tracks Ayla's hard progress from "Kiri left" to an acknowledgment of what really happened to Kiri and, past that, to a tentative understanding that Kiri will always be present in the negative spaces that, as in a drawing, make everything else "full of color and shape and life." Rather than trot in a therapist or some other mouthpiece for wise counseling, the author gives her protagonist subtler (and more believably effective) help reaching that insight-most notably parents who give her space rather than unwanted advice, and her grandfather's old telephone. Placed in the tree that was planted at her birth, the phone draws passersby to make therapeutic "calls" to missed family members, including (by one 5-year-old scene stealer) a beloved deceased pet. Readers feeling Ayla's profound sense of loss will be relieved when she finds a way to live with it. Physical descriptions are minimal, but hints in the text suggest that Ayla and her family are people of color.Raw and sad but lit with occasional glints of humor and ending, as it should, on a rising note. (Fiction. 10-12)
ALA Booklist (Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)The old-fashioned rotary phone just appeared one day in Ayla's tree, the river birch her parents planted when she was born. Something told her that it was magic, that it would let a person talk to anyone they wanted to t she wasn't about to pick up the receiver, despite desperately missing her best friend, Kiri. No, she will wait to talk to them when they finally come home. For much of the story, Ayla is firmly in the denial phase of the grieving process, making her an unreliable narrator, but McGhee provides readers with enough clues to piece together the reason for Kiri's absence before the moment Ayla is able to voice the truth. Ayla and Kiri's shared love of trees shapes the narrative in ways literal and figurative, most poignantly in trees' abilities to communicate over great distances and filter nutrients to a tree in need. Inspired by Itaru Sasaki's phone booth in Japan, where people can symbolically call deceased loved ones, McGhee lays bare the powerful emotions entangled with loss while demonstrating the strength found in community.
Kirkus ReviewsThe sudden loss of her closest friend leaves a child clinging desperately to memories and connections.Deep in denial, Ayla is sure that though her lifelong bestie "went away," Kiri (who used they/them pronouns) will be back in time for their 11th birthday. But, as gradually becomes clear, "went away" means more than just a temporary absence. Cast in half-page prose poems, this grief journal sensitively tracks Ayla's hard progress from "Kiri left" to an acknowledgment of what really happened to Kiri and, past that, to a tentative understanding that Kiri will always be present in the negative spaces that, as in a drawing, make everything else "full of color and shape and life." Rather than trot in a therapist or some other mouthpiece for wise counseling, the author gives her protagonist subtler (and more believably effective) help reaching that insight-most notably parents who give her space rather than unwanted advice, and her grandfather's old telephone. Placed in the tree that was planted at her birth, the phone draws passersby to make therapeutic "calls" to missed family members, including (by one 5-year-old scene stealer) a beloved deceased pet. Readers feeling Ayla's profound sense of loss will be relieved when she finds a way to live with it. Physical descriptions are minimal, but hints in the text suggest that Ayla and her family are people of color.Raw and sad but lit with occasional glints of humor and ending, as it should, on a rising note. (Fiction. 10-12)
School Library Journal (Sun Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2024)Gr 5 Up —Best friends Ayla and Kiri love the trees that were planted in their neighborhood the year they were born. Kiri loves the white pine, while Ayla prefers her river birch. They spend hours climbing the branches, sending special signals, and imagining themselves as trees, tall and strong. Early in the story, readers learn that Kiri is gone. But where did they go and when will they come back? Everyone misses them, especially Ayla. One day, a strange thing appears in Ayla's tree: an old rotary phone, not connected to any wires or cables. People start using the phone to talk to those who are gone. Ayla wants no part of it though, and whenever anyone starts to talk about what happened to Kiri, she hums and sings to herself to block out what they are saying. With the passing of each very short chapter (no more than one page), readers learn through Ayla's voice why Kiri is gone. Award-winning writer McGhee has penned another memorable story. Ayla's narration beautifully captures the grieving process from the perspective of a child and the characters who surround her are supportive and caring. Beautiful pencil drawings enhance the plot, and the author even includes a few facts about trees as part of the story. The use of "they" pronouns when referring to Kiri makes the story more inclusive for all readers. VERDICT A lovely book for children (and even adults) who may be grieving; this will grab readers' hearts.—Anne Jung-Mathews
Starred Review for Kirkus Reviews (Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)
ALA Booklist (Fri Oct 04 00:00:00 CDT 2024)
Kirkus Reviews
School Library Journal (Sun Sep 01 00:00:00 CDT 2024)
The moon like a bright white ship sailing through the sky.
Tree limbs dark against the moonlight, branches reaching to the invisible sun.
Kiri's mom holding Kiri tight in her arms and dancing Kiri down the block.
My dad holding me tight in his arms and dancing me down the block.
In the bright moonlight they dance their crying babies up and down the block so we'll stop crying, so we'll be peaceful, so we'll . . .
sleep
sleep
sleeeeeeep
I picture Kiri's mom and my dad whispering the names of all the trees to Kiri and me as they dance us past:
oak maple willow
birch pine mulberry
crabapple ginkgo butternut
and all those whispers weave their way into our hearts that night, so that night of dancing with the trees becomes the night that made
Kiri and me
love trees
maybe even
want to be trees
because of their tall, strong calm
Almost all the trees on our block were planted to celebrate new babies--
oak for Pops
maple for Dad
mulberry for Mrs. S
weeping willows for Rowan and Geneva
little crabapple for Gentleman
baby birch for me
baby pine for Kiri
The oak and maple and mulberry trees are tall and wide now. They've been growing as long as Pops and Dad and Mrs. S have been alive.
But two of the trees were planted not for new babies, but in remembrance of people who passed on.
The ginkgo in honor of Mrs. S's husband, Douglas, because he loved their beautiful fan-shaped leaves.
The butternut in honor of my grandmother Randa, because she loved to eat butternuts.
Fast-forward to second grade. Kiri and I are in Mr. Nesbitt's class. He has just told us all to draw aWhat Do You Want to Be? picture.
"Imagine yourselves at age thirty," he says.
Thirty?
Kiri and I are seven. It takes a long time for us just to count to thirty. We look at each other.
"I mean, my mom is thirty," Kiri whispers.
"My parents are thirty-one," I whisper back.
Will we ever be that old? When we get to that age, will we feel old?
Thirty is so, so far in the future.
But Kiri and I know what we want to be. We've always known, known from the night our parents danced us past the trees.
I look over at Kiri, who's already drawing, sketching an outline on rough paper.
Tall brown trunk. Branches curving downward, filled with pine cones. A child with braids and a round face smiling out of the trunk itself.
"White pine!" I say.
Kiri nods and smiles. Their own white pine, planted in front of their house at the end of the block when Kiri was born, is already taller than they are.
My turn.
I pick up a tan crayon and a white crayon and a green crayon and begin to draw.
White trunks split at the base and curve upward. Papery branches float out and up. Green leaves dance on limbs.
"River birch!" Kiri says.
"Yup!"
Then:
"TREES?" Martina says in her Martina voice. "Kids can't be TREES."
Martina always, somehow, knows what to say to make others feel bad.
Right away my hand covers up the drawing. Right away Martina's eyes flash and she smirks. She knows she's gotten to me.
Martina always gets to me.
But not to Kiri.
"What's your problem, Martina?"
Kiri is calm, and their voice is soft, and their question sounds like a question but isn't. What Kiri is really saying isback off.
"Mr. Nesbitt told us to draw what we want to be, right?" Kiri continues. "And Ayla and I want to be trees."
Kiri has power.
Kiri has presence.
Kiri is already like a tree.
"Ayla and I are dreaming big," Kiri says to Martina. "Why shouldn't we?"
Yeah, why shouldn't we? I think, and we look at Martina until she frowns and backs away.
Kiri makes everything better.
That day in Mr. Nesbitt's class is the day I learn you don't have to make up an excuse for what you want to be.
You can just dream big.
Kiri and I are ten now. Second grade was a long time ago, but we still dream big.
I still think about that day, though. I see Martina's face and the way she backed slowly away from our table, as if there were a force field around it.
I see Mr. Nesbitt's head, bent over his desk. His dark hair fallen across his face, and his pencil scribblingshhh-shhh-shhh across the same rough paper the rest of us used back then.
I wish Kiri were around right now. It's easier to dream big when they're with me.
Junie For Short must wish Kiri were here too. Junie For Short is Kiri's dog, and sometimes these days she just howls and howls.
"Junie sure misses Kiri," my mom says. "Just like the rest of us."
"Her name is Junie For Short," I say. "Don't call her Junie."
Junie For Short's real name is Juniper, but that name was too big for the tiny puppy she used to be. So Kiri and I nicknamed her Junie, for short, only what stuck was the whole thing: Junie For Short.
I don't howl, but I miss Kiri too.
I picture Kiri, calm and strong, like a tree.
Kiri, come home.
Just as I'm thinking that, Junie For Short, all the way down the block at Kiri's house, begins to howl again, as if she can hear my thoughts.
"That dog's always crying these days," says a voice from the sidewalk.
"I bet she misses Kiri," says a child's voice, and at the sound of those voices I stay
still
still
still
in my birch tree, because I know the voices are Gentleman and his mother. Gentleman is a nickname too. His real name is Fraser, but no one calls him that except his parents, and only when they're angry with him.
Which is a lot.
Not today, though.
Since Kiri left, I try to avoid Gentleman, but it's kind of impossible because he lives on our block.
He keeps asking me about Kiri, like he's worried or something, like he wants me to talk. Like he doesn't like me being quiet.
He tells me to call Kiri.
"I can't," I tell him. "There's no phone where Kiri is."
"Text them, then."
"Gentleman. You need a phone to text."
"Well then, go visit!"
I just close my eyes and shake my head. There's a lot that Gentleman doesn't understand, about phones and a whole lot else. So as he and his mom pass by my tree, I shrink up against it, hoping he won't see me.
It's futile. Up he comes to me in my tree. Five years old and full of swagger. The top of his head, with its sproingy wild curls, bobs in my direction.
You can't deny it, Gentleman's a cute kid.
But he's also a pain, with his constant chatter. His constant But why are you so quiet these days andWhy don't you just call Kiri.
"Go home, Gentleman," I say. "Your mom's going to start yelling for you any second."
Through the birch leaves I see his mom's almost at their apartment building.Hey! Come back and get your kid, I think.
But then I see that Gentleman doesn't look like his usual self. His eyes aren't bright, the way they usually are. He just looks at me.
Then: "Can I tell you something, Ayla?"
I shrug. It's no use to say no. If Kiri were here, we'd give each other a secrethere he goes again look.
He looks at me with those un-bright, un-Gentleman eyes.
"Ayla," he whispers. "Sweetheart died."
"Oh no! Sweetheart, your gecko?"
He nods. Leans against a low limb of my birch tree. His mouth is pressed tight in a way that looks the way my own mouth suddenly feels, which is adon't cry sort of feeling.
Those eyes of his. So sad.
This is terrible.
The idea of Sweetheart being dead is too hard to handle. Gentleman loves that lizard as much as Kiri loves Junie For Short.
"How did Sweetheart die?" I ask.
"My mom says 'How should I know, I'm not a vet,'" he says. "My dad says I probably fed her something bad for her."
"Like what?"
"Like a Cheerio," he whispers. "Sometimes. For a treat."
It doesn't seem as if a Cheerio once in a while would kill a gecko. And it seems like a mean thing to say to a little tiny kid who just lost their best lizard friend. But Gentleman's parents aren't like mine.
"Now I know why Junie For Short keeps howling," he says. "It's because she misses--"
Suddenly Gentleman's voice gets quieter and quieter and I can't hear what he's saying.
Or maybe his voice doesn't get quieter. Maybe I can't hear him because I shut my ears down.
If you think
lalala or nonono
LOUD
inside your own mind . . .
LALALA
it drowns out everything in the outside world.
Remember this. It's a useful skill when someone says something you don't want to hear.
Excerpted from Telephone of the Tree by Alison McGhee
All rights reserved by the original copyright owners. Excerpts are provided for display purposes only and may not be reproduced, reprinted or distributed without the written permission of the publisher.
An unforgettable story of grief and the support of community as a young girl, faced with aching loss, begins to understand that what we love will always be with us.
Ayla and her best friend Kiri have always been tree people. They each have their own special tree, and neighbors and family know that they are most likely to be found within the branches. But after an accident on their street, Kiri has gone somewhere so far away that Ayla can only wait and wait in her birch, longing to be able to talk with Kiri again.
Then a mysterious, old-fashioned telephone appears one morning, nestled in the limbs of Ayla's birch tree. Where did it come from? she wonders. And why are people showing up to use this phone to call their loved ones? Especially loved ones who have passed on.
All Ayla wants is for Kiri to come home. Until that day comes, she will keep Kiri's things safe. She'll keep her nightmares to herself. And she will not make a call on that telephone.