Kirkus Reviews
A quirky preteen fights misogyny and toxic social norms.Dr. Who superfan Lo Simpson, 12, would rather be planning her next cosplay than shopping for bras or giggling over boys. Unfortunately, that's all her longtime best friend, Jazz, seems to want to do-that and infiltrate the ultra-popular It Girls clique, even if it means leaving Lo behind. Unsure of who she is without Jazz, Lo has to find her own way through the maze of middle school. A mutual love of comics and Dr. Who connects Lo to a new crowd, where she feels like she can be her authentic self. With their support, Lo finds her voice and learns how to use it, whether that means breaking up an uncomfortable game of spin the bottle or facing down her school principal on issues of gender equality. Lo documents the ups and downs of her life with confessional letters to the Tenth Doctor that some readers may find border on cringey. Although her approach is occasionally heavy-handed, Florence tackles topics such as sexism, consent, and menstruation with a matter-of-fact tone that will resonate with readers. She paints a hopeful, if sometimes overly simplified, picture of how one person can instigate change for themselves and others. Characters are minimally described physically; diversity in family structure and gender identity is represented among the cast members.A thoroughly modern coming-of-age tale. (Fiction. 9-13)
School Library Journal
(Fri Mar 01 00:00:00 CST 2024)
Gr 5 Up— A middle schooler used to living in her best friend's shadow learns how to stand out and speak up, not just for herself but for her whole school. Twelve-year-old Lo's best friend, Jazz, seems to be outgrowing her. Instead of wanting to cosplay and obsess over Doctor Who , Jazz is now interested in clothes, boys, and popularity. Through confessional, unmailed letters to Doctor Who, Lo wishes for advice on how to be brave and seeks solace in her loneliness. After Jazz ditches Lo for the "It Girls," Lo stumbles across a new friend group that shares her interests. When Lo comes to Jazz's rescue on a day she unexpectedly gets her period and bleeds through her pants, Lo develops a new interest: getting the school to provide free period products in all bathrooms. Working with her new friends (including nonbinary Zev, who helps make sure Lo's plans and language are inclusive) and eventually some unexpected allies, Lo addresses the need for necessary hygiene products and speaks up about consent, sexual harassment, and double standards at her school. Told at a quick pace with short chapters and plenty of dialogue, this story, rife with themes of regeneration (which any one-sided Doctor Who pen pal knows all about) and transformation, unflinchingly tackles big issues and emphasizes the importance of speaking up for oneself and on behalf of others. VERDICT A compelling look at friendship, activism, and self-confidence.— Amanda MacGregor