Kirkus Reviews
Journalist Miller follows three first-generation college students through the 2019-2020 academic year and beyond.All are politically liberal from low-income backgrounds and conservative areas. Briani, the daughter of a Dominican mother and undocumented Mexican father, left Lawrenceville, Georgia, for the Ivy League: New York's Columbia University. Conner and Jacklynn, a White couple, navigate a rocky long-distance relationship; Conner attends Columbia, while Jacklynn attends community college back home in Ozark, Missouri. The evergreen challenges of making friends, dealing with homesickness, and managing heavy workloads are compounded by additional stressors, including impostor syndrome, pressure to make parents' sacrifices count, and the gulfs between their backgrounds and those of their more privileged-and occasionally oblivious-classmates. Conner and Jacklynn discuss growing up with family members who experience mental illness and addiction. The Trump administration's harsh rhetoric and policies around immigration figure frankly in Briani's poignant discussions of racism and her parents' political conservatism. Family members' supportive and occasionally opposing viewpoints illustrate the complex ways that being a first-generation student affects the whole family. Interspersed news headlines detail the arrival of Covid-19, which further highlights economic inequalities and upends the trio's educations, and the protests surrounding George Floyd's murder, which highlight racial inequality. Though the frequent perspective and topic shifts occasionally feel disjointed, they also reflect a chaotic year rife with tough issues. The book ends on a hopeful note, emphasizing the students' resilience.Many students will feel seen; others will find their eyes opened. (author's note) (Nonfiction. 13-18)
School Library Journal
(Mon May 01 00:00:00 CDT 2023)
Gr 9 Up— This is a wonderfully pieced together narrative of three students' experiences as first-generation college students in the midst of a pandemic. Though the focus is not on the pandemic itself, the lives of the students are obviously impacted from the unsettled state of the world during 2020 and beyond. The flow and organization of this informative book allow readers to get immersed in the lives of each of the three students, their friends, and families. Readers will often find their hearts aching and want to help these students as they share intimate and vulnerable parts of their experience. This will not only inform prospective students of a small variety of options and experiences, but provides a very deep dive into those three experiences. For educators, this will also serve to inform them of tribulations that many students, not just first-generation students, encounter throughout their high school senior year, as well as the first year of higher education. VERDICT A great auxiliary purchase for any high school library and professional collections.— Samantha Hull