ALA Booklist

This seventh adventure in Jacques' popular Redwall saga harks back to Mariel of Redwall (1992) and features the feisty mousemaid Mariel as well as her father, Joseph the Bellmaker. Having had no news of Mariel for several seasons, Joseph is worried and rightly so he discovers when Martin the Warrior gives warning in a dream. Joseph soon finds himself sailing south with a small band of friends to confront the diabolic Foxwolf Nagru, who not only has conquered the kingdom of Southward, but also has imprisoned Mariel and her companions. As usual in the series, the story juxtaposes the experiences of several separate groups of animals, both good and bad, most of whom come together for the final conflict. The expected deeds of derring-do and the violent battle action also are present as are the warmth, the endearing dialectal dialogue, and the established line between good and evil as represented by the characters. Jacques spins another irresistible tale for Redwall fans, who will enjoy meeting old friends and following their exciting new exploits. (Reviewed Apr. 1, 1995)

Horn Book

In this latest treat for fans of the Redwall series, the same surefire combination of evil villains and brave heroes battle to save innocent lives and preserve the blissful peace and plenty of the world of Redwall Abbey. The adventure positively bulges with suspense, clever tactics, humorous characters, gargantuan and delicious feasts, and engaging young beasts.

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

"For the seventh volume of the Redwall series, Jacques sticks to the tried-and-true formula—action aplenty and a huge cast of woodland creatures—that has won him such a dedicated following," wrote <EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC"">PW. Ages 10-up.<EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC""> (Feb.)

School Library Journal

Gr 4 Up--Fans of Jacques's books will be delighted to see this one hit the shelves. The story has four distinct settings: Castle Floret, where a fox dressed in a wolf skin rules as the Urgan Naguru, chief of the Horderats; Mossflower Abbey, where two infants befriend Blaggut, a surprisingly gentle Searat; Southsward, where a band of river otters and moles fight to protect the Squirellqueen Serena and her son Truffen; and the bounding main, where the title character, Joseph the Bellmaker, and his band of Redwall adventurers join forces with sea otter Finnbarr Galedeep, skipper of the Pearl Queen, to search for Joseph's daughter Mariel. With the exception of the Redwall Abbey folks, all points converge at Castle Floret for a grand battle, with fights to the finish for the bad guys, and a grand celebration feast for the victors. This is storytelling at its best. Adventures abound, and with them comes heartache. Not every beast survives to the end of this story, and Jacques is wise enough not to perform too many miracles. Characters are easily identified by their speech and the rabbits, with their ``toodle pip, wot?'' are a positive delight. It is not necessary to have read any other Redwall books to make sense of this one, though new readers will undoubtedly demand the other titles after finishing it.--Patricia A. Dollisch, DeKalb County Public Library, Decatur, GA