ALA Booklist (Mon Dec 01 00:00:00 CST 2008)

The denizens of the forest notice that something is amiss. Tree branches that were there the day before are gone, and worse me trees aren't there at all. They all blame each other, but each turns out to have an alibi. So together they launch a full-bore investigation, which consists of pretty much getting nowhere. Until, that is, they discover a paper airplane with telltale bear prints that lead them to the culprit. Turns out the bear just wanted to win a paper-airplane contest so bad he had run out of paper perfecting his model and cut down the trees to make more. The artwork, clean and simple and inviting, is the highlight, with adorably offbeat critters and subtle visual jokes, a few of which younger readers may not catch on to (the pig's alibi is that he was busy making bacon at the time), but most will garner a share of grins. True, there isn't much of a message ide from not wasting paper t it's funny and charming and weird, with little giggles to be found again and again.

Horn Book (Mon Feb 06 00:00:00 CST 2023)

When the forest animals notice that some trees are missing branches, they launch an investigation. Meanwhile, readers will spot a bear sneaking around with an ax, then see a flyer tacked to a tree advertising a paper-airplane competition. The story's details are so funny (especially the sight of otherwise normally proportioned animals with stick legs) that the respect-the-land message goes down easy.

Kirkus Reviews

"There was a time in the forest / when everything was not as it should have been." One autumn, the trees begin to vanish. At first the woodland creatures blame one another, but as the seasons change, they launch a full investigation, complete with yellow crime-scene tape. When a moose tips the investigators off, they follow the evidence to the bear's house. Driven by his family's legacy of paper-plane champions, the repentant bear explains he chopped the trees to make practice planes. The animal court requires the bear to plant replacement trees, but they also help their new friend by creating a giant paper plane out of his crumpled-up, failed aircrafts. Jeffers's illustrations are meticulously designed, from the characters' expressive eyeballs and stick-figure legs to the use of negative space and the way the text interacts with the artwork. Sophisticated readers may giggle over the mystery and mock trial, and adults may admire the undeniably hip artwork, but the story's message is a bit convoluted, mixing themes of forgiveness, eco-consciousness and teamwork. (Picture book. 6-9)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

Jeffers’s (<EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC"">The Incredible Book-Eating Boy) forest creatures have dots for eyes and sticks for legs; they live in tidy holes in the ground, equipped with home offices and washing machines. Responsible citizens, they notice that trees in their forest are missing big branches, and organize themselves to find the perpetrator—readers know from the outset it’s the bear, in need of paper for a paper airplane contest. The drama unfolds in neatly paced vignettes and comic book–style panels with the rounded corners of old television sets. Jeffers joins the speech balloons to his characters’ mouths with ruled pencil lines; his spidery writing is a sweetly incongruous vehicle for fast-moving patter (“I’ll be the detective and you can be the judge,” the beaver tells the deer. “Why do I have to be the judge?’” the deer protests, and waves a hoof toward the pig. “Why not him?” “I’m the prosecutor, that’s why,” says the pig). The conclusion nods toward forgiveness and restorative justice, but it’s the anti-crime tape that gets the laughs. Jeffers lobs a joke or two over the heads of young listeners, a gesture that will be welcomed by presiding adults. Ages 3–5. <EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC"">(Jan.)

School Library Journal (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 CST 2009)

K-Gr 3 There's something amiss in the forest, as branches are mysteriously disappearing. At first, the animal friends accuse one another but when alibis pan out, they realize that they have a thief on their hands. Setting out to solve the mystery, they discover that the bear has been stealing branches and making them into not-very-good paper airplanes for a competition. After a short trial, he confesses and agrees to replant the trees he has destroyed, and the other critters help him reuse the wasted paper to create a prizewinning entry. Managed forestry is the theme of this book that features folk-art-style animals with funny little stick legs. The mixed-media illustrations nicely complement the spare yet eloquent text. Though this clever title may need hand-selling to readers, teachers will welcome it for lessons on the environment. Angela J. Reynolds, Annapolis Valley Regional Library, Bridgetown, NS, Canada