ALA Booklist (Mon Feb 01 00:00:00 CST 2010)

High-school-junior Mike Semak has worked hard to earn his starting position in center field on his varsity baseball team. He finds inspiration and training tips by closely following the Web site of his hero, Billy Budd (a fictional member of the Yankees). Mike's dream year becomes complicated after the arrival of Oscar, a Dominican who threatens his position. In addition, Mike contends with a stale relationship with his girlfriend, as well as required community service with the school's Cyber Club. The novel includes intriguing ethical issues, but there are too many of them, and the plot spirals out of control as it follows its multiple strands about a coach's personal secrets, illegal-immigration charges, a disappointing meeting with Billy Budd, and Mike's new romance (including sex) with Kat, a track star whose nickname is Tigerbitch for her violent mood swings. It's the novel, not the players, that are on steroids here, but Lipsyte is a master at sports fiction, and the baseball sequences are first rate.

Kirkus Reviews

Mike is a star on his high-school baseball team. He models himself on his Yankees hero Billy Budd, even using his name as a mantra. But life is far from simple. A new, talented teammate might take over Mike's position in center field, and Mike's coach is frighteningly controlling, demanding absolute, unquestioning loyalty at the expense of honesty and compassion. The fast-paced plot reads like jumbled episodes of CSI or Law & Order , with illegal immigrants, computer hacking, identity theft and more. The computer geeks, jocks, radicals and the mega-star ballplayer are all borderline caricatures, but there are elements of truth and humanity in most of them. As Mike caroms from one crisis to another, he gains some important insights and finds his allegiances shifting. In his efforts to engage his audience, Lipsyte closely approximates the language patterns of teenagers, but he also includes scenes of underage drinking, pill popping and sexual activity, skewing this title to older teens. (Fiction. YA)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

Lipsyte again shines light on the dark corners of high school jock culture, this time focusing on the corrupt adults who let kids make bad choices so long as the people in charge look good. Mike believes he’s the starting centerfielder until a new kid, Oscar, shows up. Oscar’s past is murky, but his skills are evident. Is he really a high school–age transfer student? Anxious about becoming a benchwarmer, Mike shoves a nerdy kid who is annoying him, resulting in weekend community service helping the school’s Cyber Club. These eye-opening sessions reveal that the maniacal baseball coach, who also serves as the school’s dean of discipline, either has something of his own to hide or serious control issues. Mike wrestles with increasingly hard choices—should he please the coach by delivering dirt on his Cyber Club buds (including the foxy but tortured Katherine), or maintain his integrity and lose a chance at a baseball scholarship? Though this one doesn’t pack the wallop of <EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC"">Raiders’ Night (2006), Lipsyte delivers another thoughtful, entertaining sports drama. Ages 12–up. <EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC"">(Apr.)

School Library Journal (Thu Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2010)

Gr 7 Up-Mike Semak's chances of becoming star center fielder and senior team captain are jeopardized when he loses his temper with a geeky classmate, Zack. The sweet spot on the baseball team becomes even more elusive when a cocky cleanup batter, Oscar Ramirez, arrives out of nowhere with a murky birth date and questionable immigration status. Mike's penance for fighting is to help out at Cyber Club, but he learns that Coach Cody purposefully assigned him to spy on Zack and other "pukes" he suspects are hacking into the school network. There, he falls for Kat, a smart and contentious girl who seems the antithesis of his girlfriend, Lori, a pretty baton twirler. Conflicted about Kat, his coach's paranoia, and his father's possible role in bringing the Ramirez family to town, Mike looks to his major league idol, Billy Budd, whose blog has always provided sound advice about baseball and other life matters. Mike wins a contest to meet his longtime hero, only to be disappointed by the "dumb jock" reality, and finds his own moral compass to solve his problems. Appealing primarily to a jock culture, Lipsyte's characters are fairly stereotypical, especially in Coach Cody's military approach to sports and discipline, and in Lori's portrayal as a giggly boy pleaser with a "pert butt and boobs." Mystery and relationship subplots may engage a wider audience, but the story shines in the play-by-play game and practice descriptions. While some real major league names are dropped, fictional Billy Budd's portrayal as a celebrity carefully conceived by media handlers is an element that won't be lost on teens. Vicki Reutter, Cazenovia High School, NY

Voice of Youth Advocates

As the school year starts, Mike's position as a starter on his high school's Varsity baseball team seems all but assured. The coach likes him, he's a natural leader, and his skills are impeccable. Mike's whole life revolves around baseball. When he's not on the field, he's training or reading tips from his hero, a centerfielder for the New York Yankees. When the coach brings in a new, more talented player to compete for Mike's position, Mike's life begins to change. After a fight in the hallway with the leader of the computer club, Mike becomes caught in the political struggles behind the scenes of his suburban New Jersey high school, forcing him to define himself and evaluate his place in the world. Best known for The Contender (HarperTeen,1987), Robert Lipsyte has an ability to write novels in which sports action springboards the protagonists toward larger issues in their lives. In this novel, the action on the field is tense and well-written. Off the field, though, the book suffers a bit from a plot that involves obsession, identity theft, illegal aliens, dysfunctional families, relationship issues, and the dangers of hero worship and unquestioned loyalty. This scattershot approach to a theme causes the novel to occasionally lose its focus. Overall, it is a solid novel that may appeal to reluctant readers. School librarians are warned, however, that the novel's inclusion of underage drinking and discreet sex, while organic to the story, may alarm parents.ùSteven Kral.