ALA Booklist (Thu Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2010)

All-boy Oliver Keaton, baseball mitt in hand, is sure that he is getting the baby brother he has always wanted. Of course, he doesn't. When his parents proudly show him his baby sister, bedecked in pink blankets, he is miserable. He offers to trade with friends who have baby brothers, and he completely misunderstands the sign in the zoo that reads, "Change babies here," expecting he can go in with a girl and leave with a boy (the diapered and bare-bottomed babies are sure to elicit guffaws). He checks in the classified ads "just in case someone was selling a used baby boy." Both text and breezy cartoon illustrations are laced with humor, making this an excellent choice for reading aloud. Capturing Oliver's inner dialogue and the conflicting thoughts children have as they adjust to a new sibling and offering a twist ending, Feiffer's book is a cut above many of its kind. Although it's doubtful any new-sibling book will quite measure up to Kevin Henkes' Julius, the Baby of the World (1990), this one comes close.

Kirkus Reviews

In his one-page autobiography, Oliver Keaton makes it manifest that he wants a baby brother—and he knows he's getting one. So, when a cherubic baby sister arrives swaddled in pink, he's convinced it's a mistake. Even when his parents say baby Julie looks just like him, he isn't satisfied, because, he deduces, she would then be a he ! Oliver decides to replace Julie and spends the next year (and 17 hours) trying to find a suitable swap. No other baby seems quite good enough, smart enough or fun enough. His hopes are further dashed when the room labeled "Change Babies Here" smells so awful he has to flee before trading. Eventually, Oliver resigns himself to enjoying Julie's good qualities; after all, she's even learned to throw a ball. But when Oliver's parents announce another pregnancy.... Feiffer's text has just the right amount of wry understatement for Goode's playful watercolors to work with, delivering plenty of chuckles. Together they make a warm-hearted and witty story that will bring families together whether or not they are expecting a new baby. (Picture book. 3-7)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

When Oliver gets a baby sister instead of a brother, he's the only one who realizes that a mistake has been made. “In fact, everyone looked very happy, as if there had been no mistake at all,” writes Feiffer, previously paired with Goode on <EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC"">My Mom Is Trying to Ruin My Life. Taking matters into his own hands, Oliver tries to trade bald, unflappable Julie away for friends' baby brothers, and even braves the toxic-smelling baby-changing room at the zoo (“This is where you go to change your girl baby for a boy baby,” he explains), only to be thwarted by his growing attachment. The text offers a string of mildly funny incidents on its way to an expected ending, but Goode's wry, fluid watercolor cartooning presents a terrifically expressive cast, especially Oliver, Julie, and their dog, Chaplin. Her ink lines are the very definition of verve, her sense of comic detailing is faultless (the changing room scene is particularly vivid), and her Lilly Pulitzer palette offers plenty of visual clues that a happy ending is on the way. Ages 4–8. <EMPHASIS TYPE=""ITALIC"">(May)

School Library Journal (Tue Jun 01 00:00:00 CDT 2010)

K-Gr 3 This clever cautionary tale is nothing short of spectacular. Oliver Keaton is sure he is about to get a baby brother. Much to his chagrin, baby Julie arrives, on Groundhog's Daya good metaphor that sets the tone for the story. He attempts to trade his well-behaved baby sister for a brother. He discovers that his friends' baby brothers cry all day long, or are up all night, and scraps that option, but Oliver continues his quest to find the perfect one. In one funny scene, he notices a sign at the zoo that says, "Change Babies Here," and figures this would be the perfect place to exchange his sibling; crying babies go in, and happy babies come out. He goes inside, and the odor has him running for cover. Observant Oliver becomes quite insightful and discriminating as he compares and contrasts Julie's positive qualities to those of other babies, and a strong, protective bond develops. Then Mom and Dad announce that they are expecting again and Oliver imagines the fun "guy" activities he will someday share with his new unborn brother. How will he feel if it's another sister? The watercolor illustrations include cartoon characters with a lot of expression and an adorable Julie always dressed in pink. Some pages use ellipses, which will keep readers guessing and turning pages to get to the next plot point. The ending of this tale is heartwarming and satisfying. This wise and humorous selection is a winner for storytime or sharing one-on-one. Anne Beier, Hendrick Hudson Free Library, Montrose, NY