ALA Booklist (Fri Jul 01 00:00:00 CDT 1994)

We'd got to be friends by mistake. The theme of my enemy, my friend is at the core of this docu-novel of the Civil War. Johnny, 14, a young, white rebel soldier, is captured by a black Union soldier, Cush, a runaway slave. As they get to know each other in the mess and slaughter of battle and retreat, the two boys gradually lose their mutual distrust, and each risks his life to save the other. In a first-person narrative, Johnny describes his own change of heart from bigotry to the recognition that Cush is a person and that slavery is wrong. His own family was too poor to own slaves, but Johnny has been raised with the prevailing stereotypes about niggers. A preface entitled About the Use of the Word Nigger in This Book explains that historical accuracy requires the use of the term, that many of the kinds of people portrayed here would have used that term, and no other. It's the large canvas that will draw readers to the story, especially the facts about the battles in all their confusion and terror, though there is also some sense of the Southern kid who's not at all sure what he's fighting for. And no easy comfort is offered; whatever the outcome of the war, Cush and Johnny know that racism is still a bitter reality. (Reviewed July 1994)

Horn Book

Before Pa died of war wounds, fourteen-year-old Johnny promised that he would protect his family and not join the fighting, but his resolve weakens when he is offered four hundred dollars to transport food to Confederate troops. When he is captured by Cush, a young African-American Union soldier, an unlikely and uneasy friendship evolves. A gripping story of two young men caught by a cruel war.

Kirkus Reviews

Before dying of a wound, Pa extracts from Johnny a promise not to become involved in the Civil War and to care for the farm and family. Within days, Johnny impulsively succumbs to anger and honor, joining a supply train bound for besieged Richmond. In an attack by Union soldiers he is captured, to his deep disgust, by a black soldier, Private Cush Turner. Despite the doubts and prejudices of both, friendship and trust develop and each risks his life for the other. The Colliers examine the lives of ordinary Americans during a national crisis, exploring issues of morality and ethics through the actions, thoughts, and conversations of minor characters playing small parts in the final days of the war. They reveal differing ideas about the causes of the war and various interpretations of the Constitution regarding states' rights. Through close focus on the characters, the reader can see clearly the thoughtless destructiveness of Johnny's prejudices and the gradual understanding he achieves as he gets to know Cush. The text offers controversial viewpoints without intrusive moralizing. A fine supplement for textbooks on the Civil War, capable of provoking exciting discussions and insights. Maps; notes; Gettysburg Address. (Fiction. 10+)"

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

PW called this work """"a strong, affecting picture of the Civil War era... of the privations of the home front as well as the chaos and carnage of the battlefield."""" Ages 10-up. (Jan.)

School Library Journal

Gr 6-9-Like Patricia Beatty's Turn Homeward, Hannalee (Morrow, 1984) and Paul Fleischman's Bull Run (HarperCollins, 1993), this title gives readers a vivid portrayal of the Civil War. Johnny, 14, promises his dying father that he'll stay on their Virginia farm with his mother and younger sisters. The opportunity to strike a blow against the Union Army is irresistible, however, and the boy convinces his mother to let him join a wagon train carrying food to Confederate soldiers. He has been brought up to believe that all blacks are stupid; thus, when captured by a black Union soldier about his age who insists that Johnny teach him to read, he deliberately tricks him. Reaching the Union camp, Johnny is surprised when Cush saves him from imprisonment; as the novel concludes, he saves Cush's life. Richly drawn, the two boys exhibit many of the foibles found in people everywhere, and their developing friendship is believable. Authentic battle scenes add spice to the story. A two-page foreword discusses the use of the word ``nigger'' in the book. Sure to become popular.-Jo-Anne Weinberg, Greenburgh Public Library, NY