Horn Book (Fri Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2011)

Hayes narrates the tale of one boy's beloved, old, malodorous sneakers. He finally gives them up after a lady skunk, mistaking them for a fellow skunk, cuddles up to them; her jealous boyfriend skunk sprays them in anger. Hayes is a wonderful storyteller in person, but this wordy story doesn't gel. Caricature paintings, though garish, infuse some humor into the tale.

Kirkus Reviews

The duo that created The Gum-Chewing Rattler (2006) concocts a Garrison Keillortype anecdote sized to fit a picture book. The key character is not a skunk, as the title suggests, but a pair of very smelly sneakers. The bespectacled boy narrator refuses to stop wearing them, even after a mishap with cow pies, until the night he and his pal camp out. When a noise in the night awakens them, they find a skunk ardently nuzzling a sneaker. They watch as a large skunk appears, jealously sprays the sneaker and leaves with "my shoes' new girlfriend" tagging behind him. The innate humor is realistically illustrated with detailed full bleeds but is washed out by the voice of the first-person narrator, which attempts a childlike ingenuousness but achieves instead an unfortunately patronizing tone in print: "I stepped in the cow pie. That's not a pie cows like to eat. It's something that comes out the other end of the cow!" Without the storyteller's oral inflections, too many laugh lines fall flat. What kind of books do skunks read? Best "smellers"—but unfortunately this isn't one. (Picture book. 5-8)

School Library Journal (Fri Apr 01 00:00:00 CDT 2011)

K-Gr 3 As might be expected in a picture book about a pair of stinky tennis shoes loved by both the boy who wears them and the skunk that discovers them on a camping trip, this story has the flavor of a tall tale told around a homey campfire. Hayes's writing style is somewhat reminiscent of Janet Stevens's, and the vivid paintings, with their slightly exaggerated perspectives, blend well with the tall-tale feel. Although the ending is somewhat lackluster, the idea of stinky shoes and a skunk in love is funny. An additional purchase. Natasha Forrester, Multnomah County Library, Portland, OR