ALA Booklist
(Mon Feb 06 00:00:00 CST 2023)
%% This is a multi-book review. SEE the title World War II for next imprint and review text. %% (Reviewed Oct. 15, 1991)
Horn Book
Except for Persian Gulf, all of these books have been updated to include contemporary references (e.g., the United States' improved relationship with Vietnam in the past decade) and supplemental boxes that explore topics such as racism in the military. Although the writing is sometimes dry, the books are inarguably thorough. Drab black-and-white photos appear throughout. Bib., glos., ind. [Review covers these America at War titles: World War I, Persian Gulf War, Korean War, Vietnam War, and World War II.]
School Library Journal
(Mon Feb 06 00:00:00 CST 2023)
Gr 7-12-- Lively, clear, and thorough, these two volumes effectively capture the American experience in the two World Wars. The text of World War I in particular is nicely balanced. Bosco concisely discusses all aspects of the war, from military logistics and political maneuvering to the horrors of the battlefield. Liberal use of personal narratives and quotes along with battle descriptions and statistics gives readers a vivid sense of life in wartime. By focusing on a few key clashes, like Belleau Wood and the Argonne, the author further enlivens the text. World War II also provides a broad, well-organized overview. Chapters on specific aspects, such as the effect of the war on women and minorities, are smoothly interspersed into the narrative. Less attention is paid to the personal experiences of individuals, though, so this title is not quite as fascinating as World War I . The opening chapter, which describes Szilard and Einstein convincing Roosevelt that an atomic bomb could be made, is more confusing than exciting, and does little to capture readers' interest. Each title includes a few maps and many black-and-white photos that support the text. World War II 's index is thorough, but the one in World War I is less complete. Miguel's Second World War (1987; o.p.) and World War I (1985; o.p., both Silver Burdett), along with Messenger's Second World War (Watts, 1987; o.p.) are adequate resources with color illustrations, but do not match the thorough, readable texts of these newer titles. --Steven Engelfried, Pleasanton Library, CA