ALA Booklist (Sat Feb 01 00:00:00 CST 2014)

Heart LaCoeur (yes, that's her name) has long-standing plans to attend prom with her best friends as part of the No Drama Proma crew. Then, though, her brother's best friend Troy asks Heart to go with him at the last minute, after his girlfriend dumps him, and her friend Ryan asks her, too, while also revealing that he is gay. A coin flip seems like the best way to choose. Once the coin is tossed, the novel takes an interesting turn: in alternating chapters, the story plays out according to "Heads" (aka Troy) and "Tails" (Ryan). Complicating matters is a third boy, affectionately named Schroeder, and his story line threads through both versions of prom night. The truth is Heart is basically trapped in a prom night from hell, and readers will be eager to see if she amends her complicated "no dating" policy and gets some kind of happy ending. Toward the conclusion, the "Heads" and "Tails" versions flip fast and furiously, until the dual stories become almost indistinguishable. Czukas' debut is pure fun; at times, readers will feel as if in a John Hughes movie d that's a good thing.

Kirkus Reviews

One teen's prom night splits in two directions. Seventeen-year-old Heart LaCoeur (who's already planning to change her "porn star" name upon turning 18) has plans to attend the dance with friends as part of "the No Drama Prom-a Crew." Unfortunately, fate (in which she does not believe) inserts itself in the form of two last-minute dates: her French-class conversation partner, Ryan, and her brother's football teammate, Troy, recently dumped by his girlfriend. With the flip of a Chuck E. Cheese token, the first-person narrative splits in two. In the "Heads" version of reality, she is Troy's date and the odd girl out among the jocks and cheerleaders. In the "Tails" version, her date is gay Ryan, who has come out only to her. The night plays out in various hijinks before the split narratives collide in a somewhat predictable, but still satisfying, romantic conclusion. In her debut, Czukas gives readers a glimpse of a genuine comedic voice and surprisingly well-developed characters, but much of the book's promise is lost, victim of its own contrivance, in a choose-your-own-prom adventure without actual choices. Some genuinely laugh-out-loud moments are scattered throughout the unevenly paced narrative. This may work for readers seeking a cute and frothy prom-night romp, but anyone looking for something more substantial will be disappointed. Great characters in search of a less gimmicky narrative. (Fiction. 13-18)

Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)

High school junior Heart LaCoeur had planned to go to prom with a group of friends-as the No Drama Prom-a Crew-but suddenly gets two other invitations. Heart-s brother promises her to his recently dumped best friend, and her friend Ryan confesses that he-s gay and asks her to be his platonic date. Though readers may not think either option beats Heart-s original plan, she waffles and finally flips a coin. The remainder of the book alternates between the two paths, Sliding Doors-style. In one thread, Heart spends the night with stereotypically drunk football players and their prom-royalty dates; in the other, she has an unromantic evening with Ryan, which is mostly spent with the No Drama group anyway. Duplicate disasters occur in both storylines, which eventually dovetail for a telegraphed happy ending. While Heart-s escapades are largely (and enjoyably) silly, debut author Czukas occasionally hints at deeper issues, but abandons them. Readers dreaming of their own future proms can enjoy the hijinks, but they aren-t quite enough to sustain the story. Ages 13-up. Agent: Laura Bradford, Bradford Literary Agency. (Mar.)

School Library Journal (Sat Mar 01 00:00:00 CST 2014)

Gr 9 Up-"You can't get pregnant if you don't even have a boyfriend, right?" Heart LaCoeur has spent her life trying to not end up like her mother, who had two children by age 20 and then panicked and abandoned the family. So when prom, the most romantic night of the year, rolls around, Heart and her friends decide to attend as one big group, nicknamed the "No Drama Prom-a Club." The plan falls apart when Heart is asked to the prom by two different guys-Ryan, a theater-geek friend, and Troy, her brother's jock best friend. The novel plays out both scenarios in "Heads" and "Tails" sections, allowing readers to see the outcome of each of Heart's potential dates. Throughout both story lines, Heart relies on one of her guy friends, Chase, to help her through the chaos of the night. Eventually, Heart learns that Chase has been harboring a secret crush on her. The back-and-forth story lines of the narrator's two different dates becomes confusing to follow at times, and the plot contains many YA fiction clich&3;s (a friend coming out as gay, underage drinking, dating drama, and an absentee parent). Even so, Heart is a more-than-likable main character, and her budding romance with Chase will be relatable and win over teens, while her resolute stance on "taking it slow," even once her no-dating policy dissolves, will be appreciated by adults. Nicole Knott, Watertown High School, CT

Voice of Youth Advocates

Part I describes how Heart LaCoeur has a no-dating policy because her teen mom left when Heart and her older brother, Phil, were babies. Determined to do better, Heart believes her no-dating policy will prevent teen pregnancy. With prom night approaching, Heart plans for a group date with seven theater friends, until she gets two last-minute propositions by desperate potential dates. Ryan, from tech crew, comes out as gay while personally inviting Heart, but the theater teacher interrupts them. Troy, a jock-friend of Phil's dumped by his one love, Amy, has Phil broker his invitation. Confused, Heart resorts to a coin flip. Part II plays out in a series of theoretical coin flips where heads is dating Troy and tails is dating Ryan. Initially, the chapter-length coin flips are tolerable, but as the theoretical coin descends, its velocity increases, making for ever-shorter scenes until the story has progressed through her disastrous prom night to the point at the after-party where Heart has refriended her best friend and, in part III, even agrees to date himslowly.While middle-aged readers may find flipping perspectives increasingly dizzying, teens may like the technique. Czukas's humor saddles Heart with a best friend who calls her by myriad body part namesSpleen, Kidney, Pancreasand an aunt who thinks to pack essential items into an emergency bagincluding condoms for the girl who has no plans to be kissed. This is light reading for romance-seeking girls.Cynthia Winfield.