Paperback ©2014 | -- |
Tales. India. Comic books, strips, etc. Juvenile literature.
Folklore. India. Comic books, strips, etc.
With beautiful, intricately detailed artwork in a playful comic-book style, Williams retells eight Indian animal folktales. Elephant shakes its trunk to greet Dog, and they become close friends; then Dog is sold away, and the animals' body language shows that elephant is heartbroken til a huge double-page spread celebrates their reunion. Not every entry ends with such sweet resolution: scrawny Old Tiger tricks and eats a poor traveler; Cat pretends to be vegetarian as part of a plan to eat little birds. The simple language is elemental and eloquent: Swan, "rich in both food and friends," feels bad about a poor family close by, hungry and in rags: "they had so little and he had so much." But then the mother turns greedy, and there is no happy ending. Even the crocodiles in these stories have manners enough not to eat their friends. Best of all are the tales in which the trickster is outtricked, and kids will enjoy the message that "wisdom can overcome physical strength."
Horn BookWilliams adapts eight fables from Indian folklore; each tale leads, satisfyingly, to its just conclusion--and to a wisdom that transcends the stories' seemingly simple events. Well-told in narrative captions, the tales are much enhanced by comically informal remarks in speech balloons. Williams's ebullient gouache illustrations are in jewel-like tones of Indian art. A grand introduction to these venerable stories.
Kirkus ReviewsEight animal tales highlighting the value of cleverness and the hazards of greed are retold in Williams' signature breezy style. In the most familiar, "The Monkey and the Crocodile," she exonerates Crocodile (partially, at least) by endowing him with a nagging wife who demands Monkey's heart. In other tales, a golden bangle tempts an unwary traveler into the jaws of a "Scrawny Old Tiger," a kind "Golden Swan" ends up completely plucked after giving a feather to a needy but ungrateful woman, a canny rabbit convinces a "Foolish Lion" that a reflection at the bottom of a well is a rival lion, and, in the title story, a close if unlikely friendship that develops between a royal elephant and a stray dog survives a separation attempt. Grouped in sequential panels teeming with expressively drawn cartoon figures and framed within finely patterned borders, the illustrations glow with bright colors and brisk energy. Dropping in the occasional multisyllabic proper name for atmosphere and adding further zing with waggish side comments ("Maybe I could eat a reader instead!" mutters Crocodile's disappointed wife), Williams relates each fable economically and keeps the tone lighthearted even in the face of fatal consequences. Readers, wary or otherwise, could do far worse than dive into these witty, spirited renditions. (no source notes) (Graphic folktales. 8-11)
Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)Williams turns to the classic stories of India in this companion to Ancient Egypt: Tales of Gods and Pharaohs (2011), with which it shares a comic book-style aesthetic. Food emerges as a frequent theme in eight stories of haves vs. have-nots and eat-or-be-eaten interactions: in one story, a hungry tiger persuades a man to cross a river to retrieve a lost bangle (-Here I come, my dear spicy friend,- says the tiger, meeting the man halfway). Williams frames her vibrant cartoon panels with thematic borders, the best of which features the ramblings of a loquacious turtle whose motormouth is his (literal) downfall. Funny, wise, and entertaining from first page to last. Ages 8-12. (Aug.)
School Library JournalK-Gr 3 Whimsical, illustrated retellings of eight folktales. Though readers may not recognize these particular stories, well-known themes are all here, such as trickster characters (a rabbit convinces a lion to leap into a well to attack his own reflection in "The Foolish Lion"); tales of friendship (a dog and an elephant form an unlikely bond in the title story); and cautionary tales about greed (in "The Golden Swan," a woman plucks all the feathers from a bird, only to find them worthless in the end). By breaking the plots down into comic booklike panels and relying on the symbols of sequential art (a rain cloud over an elephant's head denotes anguish, action lines imply movement), Williams makes these potentially unfamiliar tales accessible and fun for young readers. Appropriately, characters are cartoonlike, with exaggerated facial expressions and postures. Busy, patterned backgrounds and intricate page borders rendered in brightly hued gouache and ink let these stories retain a traditional Indian tone. The text within the narration boxes and speech bubbles is concise. However, matching the comic-book format, a sly thread of humor consistently runs through these tales, such as a hungry crocodile breaking the fourth wall to quip, "Maybe I could eat a reader instead." Williams never skimps on the quirky details, and there's plenty to notice here on second and third readings. An enchanting addition to any folktale collection. Mahnaz Dar, formerly at Convent of the Sacred Heart, New York City
ALA Booklist
Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books
Horn Book
Kirkus Reviews
Publishers Weekly (Fri Oct 06 00:00:00 CDT 2023)
School Library Journal
"Funny, wise, and entertaining from first page to last." — Publishers Weekly (starred review)
Step back into ancient India as Marcia Williams brings her inviting comic-book style to eight animal folktales that continue to enchant children today. Drawing from three books of best-loved Indian folktales— the Hitopadesha, the Jatakas,and the Panchatantra —this graphic storybook collection, alive with kidfriendly illustrations, is infused with humor and warmth.
The scrawny old tiger
The talkative tortoise
The wise little pebet
The golden swan
The monkey and the crocodile
The tale of the three large fish
The foolish lion.